The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[halloween3110]

Hi there, I need some advice about this trade

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99342656&userid=279345&signature=Pm4-wlTjM4VEqkIq8MI8JA

Is it fair?
Any help would be appreciated!
Thank you 🎃

[I forgot it again]

They keep on sending me trades for my corgi, is this fair???

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99339790&userid=961352&signature=xl2LVewXWyzNkYw9Hi1RcQ

Be sure to use the link at the bottom of the page <3

Thanks! I just copied and pasted from a post a few days ago no one was seeing, so idk if it caught it all! thank you again! <3


trades/viewtrade.php?id=99339790&userid=961352&signature=xl2LVewXWyzNkYw9Hi1RcQ

[winx]

Hi there, I need some advice about this trade

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99342656&userid=279345&signature=Pm4-wlTjM4VEqkIq8MI8JA

Is it fair?
Any help would be appreciated!
Thank you 🎃

Seahorses - ~2 MAs each x, 4 MAs total

09 Valentine Husky - Mid-October tier, 0.5 MA/3.5 09 rares
Pink Cake Dog - High September tier, 2 MAs x

Their side totals to about 2.5 MA. They would need to add ~1.5 MA to make this fair rarity-wise.

[houndjaw]

How is this trade looking, lads?

[rainbowbanda]

Hi I was wondering if this trade for a light leopard is fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99342471&userid=868291&signature=p1G4mO2JfVdyhH3C_avWRw

[( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99342683&userid=838992&signature=cFuNi_JUcitqAhOBjhCCFQ
Is this fair?

[{smug lemon}]

hi!! id love help w this trades/viewtrade.php?id=99343793&userid=693258&signature=y57pJX3wmUw4FKuCwhOKkg
tysm

[kamukoma]

hi!! id love help w this trades/viewtrade.php?id=99343793&userid=693258&signature=y57pJX3wmUw4FKuCwhOKkg
tysm

2009 VR malachite (tbh i saw people calling this pet by different names but they were always talking about the same one haha) dog is worth the three month rule or 2 09 rares

on gonna try to break down their side pet by pet so sorry if this gets long haha. anyone reading PLEASE feel free to correct my math because i may get things wrong!

on their side - they have two 2010 rares, a 2011 rare, a 2011 uncommon, three 2012 uncommons, one 2012 common, two 2012 rares, two 2013 uncommons, one 2013 very common, three 2015 commons, two 2018 very commons, and a 2020 common.

adding them up: two 2010 rares = 1 09 rare, so half of your pets value

two 2012 uncommons equals one 2011 uncommon. that combined with the other 2011 uncommon equals one 2011 rare

two 2012 rares = one 2011 rare

two 2011 rares = a 2010 rare

to recap - right now the value of their pets is one 09 rare and one 2010 rare

then we have the rest of their pets, which is one 2012 uncommon, one 2012 common, two 2013 uncommons, one 2013 very common, three 2015 commons, two 2018 very commons, and a 2020 common

okay, two 2013 uncommons equals one 2012 uncommon. that combined with the remaining 2012 uncommon equals one 2012 rare.

two 2018 very commons equals one 2018 common

two 2015 commons equals a 2015 uncommon

one 2012 common

one remaining 2013 very common

one 2015 common

2020 common

at the end of it - on their end we have one 09 rare, one 2010 rare, one 2012 rare, 2012 common, one 2013 very common, one 2015 uncommon, one 2015 common, one 2018 common, and one 2020 common.

to be honest with you. i really do not want to break up the rest of the values even more, but i think its safe to say their offer is under the value for your pet - there really isnt a need to break the pets down into decimals lol. if i were you, i could not accept this trade. but if anyone else wants to chime in or correct me please do so

[kamukoma]

is this overpay on my side yes? and no I don’t mind if it is, just making sure it’s not unfair to them:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99333861&userid=114864&signature=wXtgowVnxlL13FNYbXx1pg

2019 store pets are generally worth one early 2010 rare each. i would say its overpay on your end

[Faybell]

^ Ok thank you, was just double checking. Hopefully me and my trade partner can work something out since I have a lot on their WL. :>