The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[NEOtwewy]

is this fair? it looks alright to me but not sure! :o just want to check the math

[Cerberussi]

is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=99300316&userid=870953&signature=gBwCP5RwWSTQ9-xsJ9TrGw

[Shakespeare]

is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=99300316&userid=870953&signature=gBwCP5RwWSTQ9-xsJ9TrGw

unfair to you; a 2019 store pet is like ~early '10 rare worth

[Pickaxe]

Hi, can I get some advice on these 3 trade offers:
1
2
3?

Thank you ^^

[SnoWolves]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99295517&userid=979631&signature=s7hQ-zi6OwSbwuF3fILczg

This?

^^

[toikyo]

How does this trade look?
Thank you in advance!

[Viridian Dragonkoi]

I have 2 trades at the moment that have some pets overlapping so I'm getting really nervous about which one might accept or not because it would cancel the other one and I'm unsure which is best.

The one I'm most unsure about is this:
TRADE HERE

It has a LOT of items on my side that I just KNOW will go up in value once the indexing of current item trades is more established however most users are going by the older values at the moment so I'd like to hit this somewhere in the middle.

Fair warning, it's a bulk trade for an OMGSR so it's BIG for pets too!

Am I over? Are they over? Is it about right? Answers on a postcard to...
Thank you to anyone answering, even if you can only do part of it, it would help the next person helping until hopefully we have some kind of idea of fairness (and to see if it matches what I believe or not) <3

[Viridian Dragonkoi]

Is this a fair trade for c$ ?
click me here for the trade

click
I'm curious about this ; I don't know much about the [scarecrow?] advent -- + black advent I believe is my blue eyed doggo?

thanks ahead of time <3

While everyone has their own opinions of worth, this thread states that 'A 2013 rare/very rare is worth around 17-19C$' in which case they are very much underpaying.

As for the second trade, you have a Black Advent (worth 1 -1.5 Non) and a 'Dogtag' (also known as a 'Non-tag' and worth, well, 1 'Non') on your side - For a total of 2-2.5 Nons on your side where the Patch on their side is more like 1.5-2 Nons
You could argue the BA = the Patch but it just comes down to how much you want the Patch?

Please get other opinions for both trades though!

[Bridgy1234]

I have 2 trades at the moment that have some pets overlapping so I'm getting really nervous about which one might accept or not because it would cancel the other one and I'm unsure which is best.

The one I'm most unsure about is this:
TRADE HERE

It has a LOT of items on my side that I just KNOW will go up in value once the indexing of current item trades is more established however most users are going by the older values at the moment so I'd like to hit this somewhere in the middle.

Fair warning, it's a bulk trade for an OMGSR so it's BIG for pets too!

Am I over? Are they over? Is it about right? Answers on a postcard to...
Thank you to anyone answering, even if you can only do part of it, it would help the next person helping until hopefully we have some kind of idea of fairness (and to see if it matches what I believe or not) <3

Ur banana =~1 non (100-150 09 rares)

Cupid wolf=1 la (4-6 09 rares)
Leopard plushie=1 la (4-6 09 rares)
Pockey, I’m having problems finding current info for, most recent I’m finding is saying 1 08 rare-very rare, in 2012 it was said to be an ma, but I am unsure if this is still accurate
All the other items are going for an uncommon from their year, a few may be going for a rare.

Unless I missed something that had high value, they are not asking for near enough.
Since items can be hard to value, and I’m really unsure on the current value of the pockys, I would see about a second opinion

[toikyo]

How does this trade look?
Thank you in advance!