The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SILVERSOCIO]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99236638&userid=675965&signature=axHYzeAT329U6HDi0IDmwQ

Please help if you can<3 I just need a quick second opinion on the VR // Thank you in advance <3 <3

[aliceeinwonderland]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99256728&userid=1036393&signature=vfOGS1xHaeaVscQr6-RFLw
I sent the trade so, I want to make sure I’m not doing a huge underpay and have them get mad lol

Please gimme opinions, I usually don’t care if I get a trade and overpay a bit but, I rlly don’t want them to be like “S C A M “ XD

[winx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99236638&userid=675965&signature=axHYzeAT329U6HDi0IDmwQ

Please help if you can<3 I just need a quick second opinion on the VR // Thank you in advance <3 <3

They are offering the: Green Swirl Colours Dog
It turned very rare in January 2019 - x.
This would make it worth the three month rule or 2 '09 rares.

[Neoncherry64]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99256728&userid=1036393&signature=vfOGS1xHaeaVscQr6-RFLw
I sent the trade so, I want to make sure I’m not doing a huge underpay and have them get mad lol

Please gimme opinions, I usually don’t care if I get a trade and overpay a bit but, I rlly don’t want them to be like “S C A M “ XD

Technically, that dog is worth the 3 month rule, but often gets quite a bit of overpay in the form of early rares. You are overpaying, but many people don’t want to trade a really high demand for a low demand pet.

[NEOtwewy]

how much would have to be added to the other side to make it fair? i know it's under at the moment (grinner is 12-18 '09 rares) but i just want to check my math ^_^ i calculated the other side at around 6 '09 rares by 2:1 rule, not sure if i did it right : D

this one too please! not exactly sure about item worth ^_^; they’re from 2010 valentines iirc but not sure if they have special demand like eros does, for example. i know the other side would need to add but not sure about how much!

[Sali]

Can I get some help with this trade?
** Caution huge trade

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99202916&userid=273533&signature=yJn4BK6fmfDnmjFtwnUc9g

Also this on please c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99246559&userid=273533&signature=hCbAJiVrBDOcMsznsfbRYQ

[heizou]

i'm pretty iffy on store pet values, how does this look?

edited the link woops

[GekkoCrazyy]

i'm pretty iffy on store pet values, how does this look?

Wrong link. Click here, It'll show you how to copy and paste the proper link if you're unsure how.

[winx]

hi !! could I get a few opinions on this?
i'm not too kept up w/lists and stuff nowadays <3

Their side:
2018 rare
Nick Sunback PPS - High September, ~1-2 MA, using 1.5 MA due to recent successful trade values x
Snowflake Bwolf - High Advent, 1 MA x
total -- ~2.5 MA,

Your side:
Red Panda - ~2-3 '09 rares to 0.5 MA x
2017 store pet valued at ~1 mid '09 rare x2 = 2 '09 rares
2018 store pet valued at ~1 late '09 rare = 1 '09 rare
2020 store pet valued at ~1 mid '10 rare x3 = 3 '10 rare, equivalent to 1.5 '09 rares

4.5 '09 rares + 3 '09 rares/0.5 MA (Red Panda) = 7.5 '09 rares
1 MA = 6-9 09 rares
total -- ~1 MA

It seems like they are overpaying rarity-wise; however, the pets on your side, in my opinion, have more demand as store pets. The bwolf does not have any particular demand, while the Nick Sunback PPS has fluctuating demand depending on the person.
I would get a second opinion on this one due to the demand differences.

[Loviare]

Could I get an opinion on this one please? I'm very unsure when it comes to trades involving old store pets. ^^'