The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Vully-the-vulpix]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99252407&userid=973739&signature=sXDj3lsZm6Zt9aNta-JbBA

Is this fair? ^^

No
Most of the pets are younger than yours and none of them are rares
In addition yours is a store pet

[Cady55again]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99252522&userid=973739&signature=niqB_r1efwQlDxWTQn66Mw is this fair??

[Winter Wish]

Does someone mind helping me with this trade? Thank you in advance!

Even though the rarities and dates match up [using 2;1], I'd consider this unfair to you. You have a lion + dog on their side, ande they just have better demand than the pets on your side.

Could I have another opinion on this? Thank you in advance!

[Bridgy1234]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99252407&userid=973739&signature=sXDj3lsZm6Zt9aNta-JbBA

Is this fair? ^^

no. the item is from 2009 but worth a 09 uncommon

Does someone mind helping me with this trade? Thank you in advance!

Even though the rarities and dates match up [using 2;1], I'd consider this unfair to you. You have a lion + dog on their side, ande they just have better demand than the pets on your side.

Could I have another opinion on this? Thank you in advance!

yes, rarities and date wise this is fair. looking at species it may be a tad unfair. butterfly wolves, rats, and horses/ponies tend to be harder to trade off, especially compared to cats, dogs, and lions. If this is just to complete your wl, go for it. if it is just going to go into trade groups I would try and edit for different species or pass.

[✧*vintage.smiles*✧]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99252681&userid=805817&signature=qr1QJUU8B4B2WXIai7WFzw

is tis fair? i dont know C$ values very well, thanks whoever helps.

[Funkyfandom]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99252731&userid=1004512&signature=Nga69bXyEPDe9FwSUdmS-A

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99239466&userid=1004512&signature=CqOOAts--AE4IMNDNg8-fQ

are these fair?

[Lex.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99252731&userid=1004512&signature=Nga69bXyEPDe9FwSUdmS-A

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99239466&userid=1004512&signature=CqOOAts--AE4IMNDNg8-fQ

are these fair?

I'd consider the 1st trade very unfair to you.

[NEOtwewy]

how much would have to be added to the other side to make it fair? i know it's under at the moment (grinner is 12-18 '09 rares) but i just want to check my math ^_^ i calculated the other side at around 6 '09 rares by 2:1 rule, not sure if i did it right : D

this one too please! not exactly sure about item worth ^_^; they’re from 2010 valentines iirc but not sure if they have special demand like eros does, for example. i know the other side would need to add but not sure about how much!

[JayJay]

Is this fair? I thought the Green and Yellow Toxic are worth the same? Or is the Yellow Toxic worth more? Thank you for any help!

[toikyo]

I'm not really looking for items for rare pets but I was curious about a second opinion on this trade :o