The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Free Shade]

Can I get some opinions on these 3 offers on my Raven?

3 Dogtags - Mostly curious on if the dogtags trade decently as I am aware this is overpay ;u;

UT Tiger Dog - Which of the 2 would be easier to trade down?

Sunjewel + NonBalloon + Blue Rose + Other ExList Dogs + Bulk Rares + 11 Older Items - Curious as to what their side adds up to in total


Thank you for any help ouo

[*Nevi Nova*]

How is this trade? i want the non-coon but i feel like im overpaying?

[valkyrie,,]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98075226&userid=723741&signature=YPt1CGeirDgda9DyZc7XVA
Help please (involves items)

their item is worth 2-3 nons and your flamingo is currently valued at 2-2.5 nons. this trade is technically fair but honestly up to you if you want their item or not, i don't know the demand.

[underwater kitty.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98148049&userid=577057&signature=5IfiXls4a-Xxx1qQLdV3PQ

thoughts on this trade pls?

unless the values have changed, i think the fish is perhaps slight overpay?
Last I heard
Fish - 1 MA (though I have been told that some people now view it as a bit under)
Peppermint eared dog - 6-7 '09 rares

So either fair or slight overpay depending on how you value the fish
Feel free anyone to correct me if my info is outdated - I have 2 of those fish myself so that's where my info comes from

thank you! wondering if i could get a second opinion as i’m trying to trade up to work my way to an omgsr so i don’t want to accidentally trade down

[Fishkin]

help is this fair?

[Redbud]

is this fair? i sent it!

[Grimsnarl]

--snip--
thoughts on this trade pls?
unless the values have changed, i think the fish is perhaps slight overpay?
Last I heard
Fish - 1 MA (though I have been told that some people now view it as a bit under)
Peppermint eared dog - 6-7 '09 rares

So either fair or slight overpay depending on how you value the fish
Feel free anyone to correct me if my info is outdated - I have 2 of those fish myself so that's where my info comes from[/quote]

thank you! wondering if i could get a second opinion as i’m trying to trade up to work my way to an omgsr so i don’t want to accidentally trade down[/quote]

The dog and fish are both 1 MA, neither of them seem to be in more or less demand than the other, it depends on how you feel, and who you trade, some prefer the dog bc dog, some prefer the fish bc it's a fish or bc it's Halloween themed

How is this trade? i want the non-coon but i feel like im overpaying?

If I'm not mistaken, the basilisks alone is worth 1 non, unless the RR non coon has special demand?

[elyurias]

i have two item trades im not really sure how to evaluate, since im not too sure about the worth of them and would love another opinion!

first
second

im fine with just a general evaluation of if its somewhat fair for both of us, i dont care thaat much about the specifics!

thank you in advance!

[winx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98075226&userid=723741&signature=YPt1CGeirDgda9DyZc7XVA
Help please (involves items)

UR flamingo is going for around ~2 nons, up to 2.5 nons, according to Horrors list. Demand and trade value still varying since it’s new.
Red garland is a retired store item from 2009 valued at 2-3 nons on the popular items list here: Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4608171#p135601406
So technically fair in my opinion. Cow doesn’t add much to the trade.

Please get a second opinion though. Didn’t look into any possible recent trade history with the item.

Edit;; Valkyrie for the win with the first opinion!

[employer]

How is this trade? i want the non-coon but i feel like im overpaying?

non coon= 1 non

TD tufted blood dog= 1.5 ma
baskilisk set= 1 non
griffin store pet= 2 ma
alien dog store pet= 1 ma

youre overpaying by 4.5 ma, unless the basilisk's value went down?