The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[mashira]

Really fatigued rn, second opinions highly appreciated.
Am thinking this is a no, but am unsure.

Is this fair?

[♥the♥bone♥thief♥]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98849592&userid=707713&signature=ZCmy1Uc4ER5BVBsi3am09g
could anyone help please? is this fair?

[kanni]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98849592&userid=707713&signature=ZCmy1Uc4ER5BVBsi3am09g
could anyone help please? is this fair?

personally id say no - it's a single 2021 for several much older rares which demand or no demand are worth a lot
plus there's at minimum one store pet that i recognize in there

it's like giving someone plastic pearls and asking for a handful of diamonds (not to be mean i just dunno any other comparisons :")) )

[NEOtwewy]

Really fatigued rn, second opinions highly appreciated.
Am thinking this is a no, but am unsure.

Is this fair?

the coins are from hanukkah 2014 and the grape vine is from halloween ‘13. if we go by the rule that each item is worth an uc from its year it doesn’t make up for the ‘09 and ‘10 gap. (but item worth is very subjective)

definitely unfair demand wise though (dogs being the most popular species while rats are one of the least popular)

[Pastel-Axle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98849592&userid=707713&signature=ZCmy1Uc4ER5BVBsi3am09g
could anyone help please? is this fair?

personally id say no - it's a single 2021 for several much older rares which demand or no demand are worth a lot
plus there's at minimum one store pet that i recognize in there

it's like giving someone plastic pearls and asking for a handful of diamonds

Hi, I’m the trade partner. I’m not trying to change your advice (as I can’t give advice on my own trades) but my pet is a yellow Sorbet, a 2008 Very Rare which is worth a fair bit (5-7MAs, with a MA being 6-8 ‘09 rares each if I remember correctly), not a ‘21 pet (it is a rerelease)

[frogfan]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98849592&userid=707713&signature=ZCmy1Uc4ER5BVBsi3am09g
could anyone help please? is this fair?

personally id say no - it's a single 2021 for several much older rares which demand or no demand are worth a lot
plus there's at minimum one store pet that i recognize in there

it's like giving someone plastic pearls and asking for a handful of diamonds (not to be mean i just dunno any other comparisons :")) )

Isn't that a 2021 release of a 2008 pet? here?

[kanni]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98849592&userid=707713&signature=ZCmy1Uc4ER5BVBsi3am09g
could anyone help please? is this fair?

personally id say no - it's a single 2021 for several much older rares which demand or no demand are worth a lot
plus there's at minimum one store pet that i recognize in there

it's like giving someone plastic pearls and asking for a handful of diamonds

Hi, I’m the trade partner. I’m not trying to change your advice (as I can’t give advice on my own trades) but my pet is a yellow Sorbet, a 2008 Very Rare which is worth a fair bit (5-7MAs, with a MA being 6-8 ‘09 rares each if I remember correctly), not a ‘21 pet (it is a rerelease)

Ah! Thank you for clearing that up, I didn't realize they re-released it. I appreciate it : )

[JayJay]

How fair is this trade?

Edit this one as well:
Also this trade?

Which one is better? Note I have the SunJewel so it would just be to trade, so how difficult is it to trade? Also the grapes demand? I would end up keeping the moonswirl as I need it for my collection.

[Kitkat2716]

any help is greatly appreciated! Thank you!
This too please!

[SleepyKerfuffle]

Which is the better offer of these two trades?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98768945&userid=900967&signature=iNVu6QkphcPWizWQgEWbQQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98838963&userid=900967&signature=JJy-clVd7l0KFXK2qAxGrQ