The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[winx]

how does this trade look?

Seems relatively fair to me >,> you’re getting another OMGSR in return and the dates of those pets are much older as well, which means higher value. Plus, iirc I think the 2014 dog is a revival of a 2008 design that was really popular and high in value!

(Only iffy part might be that your OMGSR design is really nice, but that’s on you on whether or not how much your consider design into the overall fairness of value LOL)

Your side:
UR Kirin — 2-2.5 nons

Their side:
Dogtag — 1.5-2 nons (using 1.5 due to low demand right now)
Line tribal — 0.25 nons
Spotted tribal — 0.5 nons
Skele PPS — 0.25-0.5 nons (using 0.25 due to RR and the fact there’s a ton of them circulating right now due to a hoard disband)

1.5 + 0.25 + 0.5 + 0.25 = 2.5 nons is what they’re offering
Technically fair rarity wise; however, the pets on their side don’t have the best demand.
Like mentioned earlier, there’s a lot of the Skele PPS circulating currently. The Dogtag’s demand is pretty low right now. Line tribal also has low demand. Spotted tribal has average(?) demand.

[♥HazelNightmare]

Can I get some thoughts on this trade?

I'm not sure what the store horse is going for right now c:

Thank you!!

This is unfair to you
Your black rainbow Kirin/unicorn goes for 1 Mid advent 6-9 09 rares) x

Their side totals 2 09 rares as their 2019 store pet goes for an early 2010 rare .
While some may trade more for the Malk dragon it’s subjective and trader based . Possibly another 09 rares or so from what I’ve seen .
Another opinion on demand aspect is always good

[winx]

Can I get some thoughts on this trade?

I'm not sure what the store horse is going for right now c:

Thank you!!

Their side:
Copper Malk dragon - only worth the three month rule, but usually gets overpay due to Malk design, can reach 3-4 09 rares as payment, but it is up to you and your trade partner on where it stands value wise
2010 rare
2019 store pet valued at ~1 early '10 rare

Two 2010 rares —> 1 2009 rare
Base value: 2 09 rares not including Malk dragon demand, with demand it would be closer to 4-5 09 rares

Your side:
Black Rainbow Unicorn - ~1 MA

1 MA = 6-9 09 rares versus their 2 or 4-5 09 rares

So, this is technically unfair to you rarity wise. Depending on where you place the Malk dragon, it could be fair, but this would mean valuing the Malk Dragon at around 5 09 rares (which would be a bit much). Even with the demand included, it is still slightly under the 6-9 09 rare value for an MA.
Hope this helps make your decision.

[JayJay]

How fair is this trade?

Edit this one as well:
Also this trade?

Which one is better? Note I have the SunJewel so it would just be to trade, so how difficult is it to trade? Also the grapes demand? I would end up keeping the moonswirl as I need it for my collection.

[TigX]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98830946&userid=306238&signature=8XlgqIJcBM6sCj4T4hjphw


is this trade fair??

[Turo0]

klick
How is this for both of us? Thank you for any help in advance <3

[boston]

would love some insight on this trade please! ty in advance <3

link

[Mikuru Senpai]

Two little item trades c:
Would they be fair ?

X
X

[k o t a]

looking for some help on this trade: https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98839359&userid=637714&signature=T9mReuCxbLtg2Lrsk1XGaw
i haven't been on consistently in a few years and i'm unfamiliar with how the demand of the shima longtail has changed. please feel free to pm me, replies can get a little lost in these threads (:
thanks! -kota

[SLOPPED!]

looking for some help on this trade: https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98839359&userid=637714&signature=T9mReuCxbLtg2Lrsk1XGaw
i haven't been on consistently in a few years and i'm unfamiliar with how the demand of the shima longtail has changed.
thanks! -kota

very unfair. with demand of the shima taken into thought, its worth 3ma. sadly