The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Cherrynoriaki]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98800960&userid=790689&signature=ewBWB6Zjftm51xg248-EyA

Is this fair? I haven't been on in a while but I feel like the event pets end up being more than common?

[goofer goblin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98800960&userid=790689&signature=ewBWB6Zjftm51xg248-EyA

Is this fair? I haven't been on in a while but I feel like the event pets end up being more than common?

i think the event pets will probably become a rare, the other side isn't fair tbh.
i wouldn't accept personally <33

[Quackers <3]

How does this offer look?

Thank you!

[Fen’harel]

Hey, so I’m really new here, and wanted to get some input if this trade is fair? I have a decent grasp with pets, but no clue how items stack with it…

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98801030&userid=1034039&signature=YtfI_am8JB4K6VFNkszw6w

Thank you for your time!

[JayJay]

could I get some input on this trade? any help is appreciated. c:

UR Aussie: average 1non
*Trade data shows trades between .75-1.25non, with more recent trades near the high end. x

Blue Toxic: .5non
Green Sorbet: .5non
Total = 1non

*I would say fair trade.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98771669&userid=652611&signature=nEWgpNf40G7RxXK1GIPQJg

Is this fair? Keep in mind the balloon dog is true date.
-DA

TD Blue Balloon: .75-1non
TD Purple Sleipnir: .25non
*truedate does not seem to make a difference here.x
Total = 1-1.25non

Purple Toxic: .5non
Non Balloon: .5non
Heavy Orange Stripes: .5MA (can get 1MA for TD but not the case here)
Zodiac Dog: ~3 '09 rares
Total = 1non + ~1MA

*I would say fairish... I've seen some TD balloons get to 1non but a lot of them go for .75non so it depends on how you value the Blue balloon.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98800702&userid=395590&signature=4Hfk9Q2NgZxI32BE92QCUA
is this a fair trade?

UR Strawberry: 1.5nons

TD Noncoon: 1non
*Some may value higher, but trade data shows 1non. x
Yellow Sorbet: .5non
'15 Galaxy Unicorn Store Pet: .5MA
Total. = 1.5non + .5MA

*I would say fair trade.

How does this offer look?
Thank you!

2× Coontail: 1.5-2non ea
*Trades are recently going on the higher end.
BEG: 1.5non
Yellow Toxic: .25-.5non
Angel Wing item: .25non
Total = 5-6.25nons

Red Cerberus: ~5nons
*A lot of players have it valued around 4.5-5non but most trades show 5non x. There is one C$ trade valuing it at 6nons but that seems to be an outliner

*I would say unfairish. Close to fair but a little over on the bulk side.

[mikuscreations]

May I get an opinion please? Thank you!
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98801809&userid=571194&signature=emNkLJ8yA7oHnDkXQ6V5zw

[Mikuru Senpai]

What about this then? c:
X

[Flicka]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98781959&userid=9355&signature=S5SJOaBPX3TTWkf5hD9htg is this fair? I don't know enough about cs math yet to know

[green.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98802392&userid=980521&signature=tQDqD0DkcAarqskm9x11Ow
is this fair?

[-Frost-]

I'm not great at knowing the worth of VRs, would this be a fair trade for my bw vr?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98786761&userid=182725&signature=bJfOuD-cx0uQP8-nUmATag

You have the “Bee Bwolf” on your side of the trade. It is on the Low October tier of Horror’s list. Based on the tier, it is worth 3 09 rares.
They are offering 2 09 rares, a 2010 uncommon, and a 2011 rare.
2010 unc = 0.5 2009 unc = 0.25 2009 rare.
2011 rare = 0.5 2010 rare = 0.25 2009 rare.
This essentially means they are offering 2.5 09 rares, which is slightly unfair to you by 0.5 09 rare.
I couldn’t find any trade data on it, so I’d recommend getting a second opinion just to be sure.

Thank you I appreciate the input, if anyone else would like to give a second opinion, I appreciate it <3

seeking a second opinion~