The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Leikindasuxkz]

I'm not quite sure on this one

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98772027&userid=1011903&signature=LKTabYsoTjm6BgTnECnLuQ

Is it fair?
Who needs to change if not? And any suggestions on how to fix it?

I could use an opinion please

[♥HazelNightmare]

ahh- I need some help with this ;0; I just don't know if I could get a better offer for my corgis xxx

This is a fair trade .

Corgis trade for 1 MA each x
Some traders may trade more , really depends on trader and how much they want the pet.

Red Toxic is worth .25 nons or 3-4 mid advents x x
While some may value the toxics at .25-5 , Red, green and yellow toxics are .25 but yellow usually trades for .5 along with the Blue and purple .

[Quackers <3]

How does this trade look for my Vixen?
And this for my BEG?

Thank you in advance!

[SeaCrest]

Before I accept, neither of these has any particular demand over the other, correct?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98795003&userid=5378&signature=uOzpVjwDOCLUYxMwpRXNiw

[winx]

Before I accept, neither of these has any particular demand over the other, correct?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98795003&userid=5378&signature=uOzpVjwDOCLUYxMwpRXNiw

Nope! This is a good swap rarity-wise and demand-wise in my opinion.
Dark Tess Dragon - First rarity: UC | 4.11 UC to R | 1.19 R to VR
Candy Cane Tess Dragon - First rarity: UC | 8.11 UC to R | 1.19 R to VR
They even both turned very rare in the January 2019 update, so they’d be fair swaps for each other.

[lucifer morningstar]

could I get some input on this trade? any help is appreciated. c:

[-Frost-]

I'm not great at knowing the worth of VRs, would this be a fair trade for my bw vr?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98786761&userid=182725&signature=bJfOuD-cx0uQP8-nUmATag

[winx]

I'm not great at knowing the worth of VRs, would this be a fair trade for my bw vr?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98786761&userid=182725&signature=bJfOuD-cx0uQP8-nUmATag

You have the “Bee Bwolf” on your side of the trade. It is on the Low October tier of Horror’s list. Based on the tier, it is worth 3 09 rares.
They are offering 2 09 rares, a 2010 uncommon, and a 2011 rare.
2010 unc = 0.5 2009 unc = 0.25 2009 rare.
2011 rare = 0.5 2010 rare = 0.25 2009 rare.
This essentially means they are offering 2.5 09 rares, which is slightly unfair to you by 0.5 09 rare.
I couldn’t find any trade data on it, so I’d recommend getting a second opinion just to be sure.

[Alaskabound]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98795821&userid=322053&signature=z8thdUprVZK_EGNpuGfZqQ

Would this be a fair trade?

They are also offering this alternative trade: https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98792751&userid=322053&signature=uuS6UD5e2UgNmv94lkeWiA

Is either of these trades fair? Which would be the more desirable trade? I don't really know the value of list pets.

Thank you in advance.

[winx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98795821&userid=322053&signature=z8thdUprVZK_EGNpuGfZqQ

Would this be a fair trade?

They are also offering this alternative trade: https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98792751&userid=322053&signature=uuS6UD5e2UgNmv94lkeWiA

Is either of these trades fair? Which would be the more desirable trade? I don't really know the value of list pets.

Thank you in advance.

For the first trade, your trade partner is massively overpaying.
Your VR warrior cat is worth 1 MA. Each of their rare warrior cats is worth 0.5 MA due to demand. They are offering 10 rare warrior cats, which is 0.5 * 10 = 5 MA in comparison to your 1 MA.

For the second trade, card dogs are typically worth 0.5 MA. They can reach 1 MA as a true date, which isn’t the case here. Two card dogs at 0.5 MA each is 1 MA, while your VR warrior cat is also worth 1 MA. This is a much fairer trade for your trade partner than the first trade.