The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Pastel-Axle]

Can I please get an opinion on this trade before I accept? Is this fair to my end?

their side: 5.5-8 09 rares
lava/fire dragoncat = 0.5 MA
manticore lions may get overpay and could be valued between 2 09 rares and 0.5 MA

Your side: 7 09 rares
zodiac dogs are usually valued at 2-3 09 rares or 0.5 MA (closer to 3.5 09 rares) as a rerelease, i'd value yours at 3.
2017 store pets are said to be worth a mid 09 rare each
the other pets add up to 2 09 rares each

Would I be better off accepting this or holding onto my pets? 5.5-8 ‘09 rares is quite a large range of values ;v;

[heartz4faye]

Is this fair? I want to accept but I'm not really sure. Fire elemental cat is on their wl and the pets/items on their side are on mine.
here

I'd like to get more opinions on this. Trade is updated; I thought they were overpaying so I sent it back to them. Could someone teach me the values of the pets on their side + on my side? Link

[ferretjuice]

Can I please get an opinion on this trade before I accept? Is this fair to my end?

their side: 5.5-8 09 rares
lava/fire dragoncat = 0.5 MA
manticore lions may get overpay and could be valued between 2 09 rares and 0.5 MA

Your side: 7 09 rares
zodiac dogs are usually valued at 2-3 09 rares or 0.5 MA (closer to 3.5 09 rares) as a rerelease, i'd value yours at 3.
2017 store pets are said to be worth a mid 09 rare each
the other pets add up to 2 09 rares each

Would I be better off accepting this or holding onto my pets? 5.5-8 ‘09 rares is quite a large range of values ;v;

i would keep your pets, you still have your 2 stores plus a zodiac and other various rares <3

[240SX]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98676061&userid=536230&signature=aRMgMfjNyY2N8YPzrsf2Jw

We were both wondering if this is fair, both of us don't know the rarities on these plushes. Any help would be appreciated!

[Lorde.]

hi! my trade partner wants this for their red toxic, is it fair for me? x

[winx]

Is this fair? I want to accept but I'm not really sure. Fire elemental cat is on their wl and the pets/items on their side are on mine.
here

I'd like to get more opinions on this. Trade is updated; I thought they were overpaying so I sent it back to them. Could someone teach me the values of the pets on their side + on my side? Link

Your side:
Fire Malk Elemental - 1 MA - x
1 MA = 6-9 09 rares

Their side:
2010 rare bun - three month rule
RR March 2009 White Skull Cat - three month rule or 2 09 rares
1 2020 rare
2 2021 rares
Pink aran sweater - Christmas '15 - 2015 UC
Birman Plushie and Black Cat Plushie = Christmas 2016 = 2016 Uncommon each
2019 butterfly wings - 2019 uncommon
2020 angel statue - 2020 uncommon
2020 black cat - 2020 uncommon
2020 Christmas CS Dog Plushie - 2020 uncommon
1 2010 rare --> 0.5 09 rares
2.5 09 rares total on their side + a bunch of newer rares/uncommons
In my opinion, this is pretty unfair to you if you hold value to dates. 2.5 09 rare equivalents + newer rare pets can't reach the 1 MA (6-9 09 rare) basis.

[Lorde.]

sorry i didnt realise i was bumping this thread thats my bad (did it a few times haha)

[DemetriusIsMyDad]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98677665&userid=966340&signature=iWhPfwkIlxtUpH6T45c8Fg

This looks about right but I wanna make sure

Both are 2010

[Spottedleaf16]

Would the 2008 Bone PPS

be a fair trade for the 2009 Malk Mutant?


How much more would need to be added to be a fair trade for a 2009 Shima Longtail?

[heartz4faye]

Your side:
Fire Malk Elemental - 1 MA - x
1 MA = 6-9 09 rares

Their side:
2010 rare bun - three month rule
RR March 2009 White Skull Cat - three month rule or 2 09 rares
1 2020 rare
2 2021 rares
Pink aran sweater - Christmas '15 - 2015 UC
Birman Plushie and Black Cat Plushie = Christmas 2016 = 2016 Uncommon each
2019 butterfly wings - 2019 uncommon
2020 angel statue - 2020 uncommon
2020 black cat - 2020 uncommon
2020 Christmas CS Dog Plushie - 2020 uncommon
1 2010 rare --> 0.5 09 rares
2.5 09 rares total on their side + a bunch of newer rares/uncommons
In my opinion, this is pretty unfair to you if you hold value to dates. 2.5 09 rare equivalents + newer rare pets can't reach the 1 MA (6-9 09 rare) basis.

If this is the case, should I ask them to add more? /gen