The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[goofer goblin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98673211&userid=737315&signature=Uicqx_Nm_UAaDeBJUvcRLA

Is this fair? Thank you

i wouldn't say totally fair, but close.
sunjewel trades for 3-3.5 non, while ur cat trades for 2.5-3 non <3

[winx]

I'm not sure if the 2009 rare robot dog has any demand, is this a fair offer? I was going to accept it but I wanted to make sure first

The Silver Robot Dog is worth the three month rule, so fair swap for an 09 rare. Any additional demand is up to you and your trading partner.

They are offering -->
3 2010 rares = 1.5 09 rares
+ 2021 uncommon + 2022 store pet (equivalent to an early 2011 rare, 0.25 09' rare)
Total:
1.75 09 rares on their side + 2021 uncommon

[Ghōst]

I'd like to know how fair this is? I'm not too knowledgeable on C$.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98675597&userid=792268&signature=FzXA6rPZLyFL-L0Bn_OxWQ

bump

[koala89silly]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98673211&userid=737315&signature=Uicqx_Nm_UAaDeBJUvcRLA

Is this fair? Thank you

The UR tess cat goes for 2-3 nons, more consistently 3.

The Sunjewel goes for 3-3.5 nons.

As for the commons and uncommons, their side is overpaying by a 2021 common.

Personally, I'd keep the Sunjewel, though you might want to get a second opinion. Hope this helped!

[winx]

I'd like to know how fair this is? I'm not too knowledgeable on C$.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98675597&userid=792268&signature=FzXA6rPZLyFL-L0Bn_OxWQ

bump

Way unfair to you. That would pretty much pay for just one of those rare warrior cats.
Looking at the successful C$ trades here, rare warrior cats have been getting between 150-200 C$. 200 C$ values were reached for true dates most commonly.
I recently sold one of mine for 175 C$. If I base it off that, then they should be paying closer to +-350 C$ for both.

[Merp.com]

the trade

Hello I value my pet at 1.5 MA since it's truedate. Would this be fair for it?

[Ghōst]

I'd like to know how fair this is? I'm not too knowledgeable on C$.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98675597&userid=792268&signature=FzXA6rPZLyFL-L0Bn_OxWQ

bump

Way unfair to you. That would pretty much pay for just one of those rare warrior cats.
Looking at the successful C$ trades here, rare warrior cats have been getting between 150-200 C$. 200 C$ values were reached for true dates most commonly.
I recently sold one of mine for 175 C$. If I base it off that, then they should be paying closer to +-350 C$ for both.

Thank you :]

[blue hydrangea]

I'd like to know how fair this is? I'm not too knowledgeable on C$.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98675597&userid=792268&signature=FzXA6rPZLyFL-L0Bn_OxWQ

the rare warriors usually go for 0.5 MA which is about 150 C$, together they shoud be about 300
this guide is useful as a starting reference for pricing valuable pets

[Ghōst]

I'd like to know how fair this is? I'm not too knowledgeable on C$.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98675597&userid=792268&signature=FzXA6rPZLyFL-L0Bn_OxWQ

the rare warriors usually go for 0.5 MA which is about 150 C$, together they shoud be about 300
this guide is useful as a starting reference for pricing valuable pets

Thank you so much :]

[blue hydrangea]

the trade

Hello I value my pet at 1.5 MA since it's truedate. Would this be fair for it?

the 2013 phoenix store pets only trade for 0.5 MA currently, so no