The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[moonviewing]

help with this please?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98498747

please use the link at the bottom of the page!

[rainfall.]

opinions? i think i prefer to keep the store pets, but i'm not sure. thank you!! <3

[Kayu and Pai]

fixed, havent logged in, in awhile so forgot ^^"

[Pastel-Axle]

opinions? i think i prefer to keep the store pets, but i'm not sure. thank you!! <3

*Please* get a second opinion as I’m struggling to find trade data on any of the stores but I believe that value-wise they’re overpaying? If I’m not mistaken the Hollyfox dog trades for around 2MAs, while your side would add up to 5 ‘09 rares based on the standard values of stores from their respective years (an early ‘09 rare for ‘16, a mid ‘09 rare for ‘17).
Again, please get a second opinion; I think the dogs are in-demand at the moment as I’ve been getting offers for mine as of late, but don’t really know how they’re trading at the moment outside of those baseline values,

[Pastel-Axle]

My trade partner and I are trying to come to a conclusion regarding the pet on their end, how’s this trade?
Trade data on the flying dogs isn’t the easiest to come by but I am quite interested in this pet, I just want to make sure things are fair to both of us!
And is this trade fair to me? What constitutes the gap in value between an early and mid ‘09 rare, assuming that’s what ‘16 and ‘17 stores respectively still trade for?

I’d prefer an answer to these as soon as possible, for the sake of my trade partners who are waiting ;v;

[kyurenine]

I got this trade just now, is it fair? I’m not too familiar with item trades.

[Ghostflake]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98500003&userid=1022867&signature=Qv3KtOSoi6RAFviymDUAAA

Help, tq

[ahirked]

I got this trade just now, is it fair? I’m not too familiar with item trades.

your item (coin stack) is from 2018 and would be worth a 2018 common or less since coin items tend to have low demand.

the curious bunny, cute goat and happy goat on their side are worth a 2021 common/uncommon ea., so even if we value your coin at a 2018 common, their side would not match up in value to that due to the year differences. strictly speaking, they would need to add one more 2021 item worth a common/uncommon to match your side, but taking into consideration that coin items are generally less sought-after than plushies/creatures, then I believe the 3 items they're offering would be fine.

opinions? i think i prefer to keep the store pets, but i'm not sure. thank you!! <3

*Please* get a second opinion as I’m struggling to find trade data on any of the stores but I believe that value-wise they’re overpaying? If I’m not mistaken the Hollyfox dog trades for around 2MAs, while your side would add up to 5 ‘09 rares based on the standard values of stores from their respective years (an early ‘09 rare for ‘16, a mid ‘09 rare for ‘17).
Again, please get a second opinion; I think the dogs are in-demand at the moment as I’ve been getting offers for mine as of late, but don’t really know how they’re trading at the moment outside of those baseline values,

tagging onto this to say that I know the trade has already been accepted, but-

Hollyfox seems to go for about 2-3 MA

stores on bottom side are worth (used this post):
- 2016 ferret = early 09 rare
- 2017 store dogs = mid 09 rare ea. (= 4 mid 09 rares)
== 5 09 rares

since 1 MA goes for 6-9 09 rares, the bottom is just under 1 MA, which still would not be fair to the Hollyfox.
also that said, I did find one trade for the ferret store pet that valued them at 1 MA each, but I found no other evidence to back this up, so am unsure as to that exactly. I also could not find exact trading data for the 2017 store dogs, but I would still tentatively say that this was unfair to the Hollyfox.

My trade partner and I are trying to come to a conclusion regarding the pet on their end, how’s this trade?
Trade data on the flying dogs isn’t the easiest to come by but I am quite interested in this pet, I just want to make sure things are fair to both of us!
And is this trade fair to me? What constitutes the gap in value between an early and mid ‘09 rare, assuming that’s what ‘16 and ‘17 stores respectively still trade for?

I’d prefer an answer to these as soon as possible, for the sake of my trade partners who are waiting ;v;

first trade-
the 2016 flying store dog is valued at an early 09 rare in the post I linked in my above response, but having a scour of trades it appears it's been valued from 1-2 09 rares (x)

with the pets on the bottom:
- 2017 store = mid 09 rare
- 2010 r dog = 0.5 09 rare
- 2010 r bunny = 0.5 09 rare
- 2021 r
== 2 09 rares + 2021 r

if valuing the dog by it's higher value of the trades outlined, then this would be fair with a tiny bit of overpay. in the alternative, valuing it at it's lower end, then you'd be overpaying with the 2010 rares. it's up to you and your partner ultimately, which end you value it at, esp as there isn't much trade data as you said.

--

for the second trade, I'd have a read of this extremely helpful post by Lennie regarding gaps between store pets!

[xxgalaxylightxx]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98496960&userid=669255&signature=CtGURnEOzS8A6GJuPCnWsw

Opinions??

[Rbpuppy]

Hi guys! Just wanted to double check this one. Last time I checked I thought toxics were worth .25 Nons but maybe that’s changed.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98493659&userid=42960&signature=QMDB7LnmWhU_ef_a953Jnw

Thanks!