The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[koala89silly]

Which bid of items is more fair?
1. this + add?

or

2. this?

Please help ASAP!

Also, is this fair?

[Lycanthia]

I don't really do C$ except for buying store pets, any advice?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98456918&userid=335209&signature=ZvA2DGq8jPKl8c-3u5YELw

[depressedanonymous,]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98454883&userid=652611&signature=iE8AnDthxmsukOgvOCsm5A

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98454896&userid=652611&signature=Z3Rh7EvvMzd9-Ruyh9Vn9w

Any help? Tysm!

[winx]

I don't really do C$ except for buying store pets, any advice?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98456918&userid=335209&signature=ZvA2DGq8jPKl8c-3u5YELw

This pet would generally be valued at the three month rule or 2 '09 rares - x. As for C$ values, you can check out this guide here to determine pricing. An 09' rare/very rare is priced between 35-55 C$. I usually split it in half, so the first half would be pricing for rares and the second half for very rares. Thus, 35-45 C$ for an 09' rare and 45-55 C$ for an 09' very rare.
In general, it seems they are overpaying since there is no particular demand for the White-Footed African Wild Dog. It trades consistently for the same amount and is not a list.

[depressedanonymous,]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98454883&userid=652611&signature=iE8AnDthxmsukOgvOCsm5A

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98454896&userid=652611&signature=Z3Rh7EvvMzd9-Ruyh9Vn9w

Any help? Tysm!

[вєσωυℓf]

Hi, can I get some help with this? Thanks ^^

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98462807&userid=770491&signature=-eXqd3YOlVwqMVbmJJIjOA

[cupidtwn]

thoughts? ^^; trades/viewtrade.php?id=98463072&userid=898252&signature=GfIDGWDwOopPX5TXoPrkOA

any help? thank youuu

[winx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98454883&userid=652611&signature=iE8AnDthxmsukOgvOCsm5A

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98454896&userid=652611&signature=Z3Rh7EvvMzd9-Ruyh9Vn9w

Any help? Tysm!

1st trade listed
their side
1 Albino January rat - Mid October list [~~3.5 09 rares / 0.5 MA]
1 Blue Light Striped rat - Mid Advent list [~1 MA or 6-9 09 rares]
1 2019 common
2 wispies from 2019 Fae Mischief Event (token items) [~1 uncommon per item from 2019] - Couldn't find any trade data, so going off the typical "uncommon from the same year" pricing
Note;; token items are worth more than free items, so it could be argued they are worth 1 2019 rare each, but it doesn't impact the overall outcome of the trade. A token would get a set of the wisps, but since this isn't a full set, I would argue two as being uncommon each.
Totaling:
3.5 + 6-9 09 rares = 9.5 - 12.5 09 rares + 2 2019 uncommons + 1 2019 common

your side
1 2009 very rare pony (turned very rare in 2018, worth pets who turned very rare around the same time) ~ 2 09' rares
1 2009 rare draft (worth three month rule or equivalent) ~ 1 09' rare
1 2010 very rare draft (worth three month rule or equivalent) ~ 1 09' rare --> 2 10' rares = 1 2010 very rare
1 2010 rare unicorn (worth three month rule or equivalent) ~ 0.5 09' rare --> 1 10' rare
Totaling:
2 + 1 + 1 + 0.5 = 4.5

4.5 < 9.5-12.5 09' rares
Thus, I believe they are overpaying.

[abbie.]

can i get any opinions on this?
thank you in advance!!

[pebblick]

is this fair?