The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[juuzou]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97948484&userid=830020&signature=y_V-BEhlCvH4cWxKhtvfNg
could I get some advice on this?

Um, I don't think this is very fair. The dog doesn't have any special demand, so its worth about 2 '09 rares, and an '09 rare is worth about 35-55C$. Going by the 2:1 rule, the other rares aren't enough to supplement the C$. Anyways, not to fair.

[VivviQ]

ARE EITHER OF THESE FAIR?


This one has many OTHER wishlist pets of mine they said I could look through but I’m wanting mostly old store pets.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97950880&userid=1024519&signature=e894vhGEIJsHJktqBAnCog

The second one.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97950875&userid=1024519&signature=Vbbv2yZR_HINJk-x27JOqQ


Please explain fairly well the worth of the pet and fairness please as I’m newer. Thank you!!

[juuzou]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97950533&userid=1003479&signature=hW3xMhoguyY4RbvbNw4huQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97950568&userid=1003479&signature=lb6O47CMq5RDIK_GUQBB5w

Are either of these fair? Idk the value of the dog or how much it fetches <\\3

I'm not seeing any special demand on the mime dog, so that's about 2 '09 rares worth. Each store pet from about '20 onward is pretty much a '10 rare. So, ur peacock trade is 2.5 '09 rares, ish, and the one with the guinea pigs is 1.5 ish (not quite sure where '19 store pets land, but it's not too far off from a '10 rare, i think).

[juuzou]

ARE EITHER OF THESE FAIR?


This one has many OTHER wishlist pets of mine they said I could look through but I’m wanting mostly old store pets.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97950880&userid=1024519&signature=e894vhGEIJsHJktqBAnCog

The second one.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97950875&userid=1024519&signature=Vbbv2yZR_HINJk-x27JOqQ


Please explain fairly well the worth of the pet and fairness please as I’m newer. Thank you!!

I'm here! So, they are asking for your PPS Lion which is known as the August PPS in the mystical naming system of CS that I have yet to get a handle on. This lion is worth ~.25 non. (1 non = 10-12 MA = 100-150 '09 rares).

First trade offer has:
- 7 reg '09 rares (warrior cats sometimes can go for a bit more than retail because of demand)
- '15 store pet = 2 '09 rares
- '17 store pet = '09 rare
- '20 rare = not worth much in the grand scheme of things
TOTAL: about 10 '09 rares

Second trade offer has:
- Pink Striped September = ~2 MA
- '13 store pet = 1 MA (no special demand)
- 5 '21 store pets = about '10 rare each = 2.5 '09 rares
(and some other pets that don't add up to much in the grand scheme of things and are just padding)
TOTAL: like 3.25 MA

The second trade is definitely the better offer! I get all my information from Horror's list and some searches on the "what is this pet worth" thread, so if you want to make that top trade fair, you can check out those resources or pm me if you have questions! (Also, I added some quick math and store pet conversions down below!)

2011 = september - low main +
2012 = high advent +
2013 = ma
2014 = la
2015 = 2 '09 rares
2016 = early '09 rare
2017 = mid '09 rare
2018 = late '09 rare
2019 = early '10 rare
2020 = mid '10 rare
2021 = late '10 rare

1 NON = ~100-150 09 rares
0.75 NON = ~70-81 09 rares
0.5 NON / 1 SORB = ~50-75 09 rares
0.25 NON / 0.5 SORB = ~25-37 09 rares

1 NON = 10-12 MA
0.75 NON = 8-9 MA
0.5 NON / 1 SORB = 5-7 MA
0.25 NON / 0.5 SORB = 3-4 MA

1 MA = 6-9 09 rares

Oct list generally = 0.5 MA,
low oct may be slightly less

[~EllaBelle~]

How fair is this?

[lawyer]

anyone know if this is a good deal?
thanks in advance!

[xayah.]

i'm not sure about this trade! i'm giving C$ for their uncommons, so with that aside, is this fair?

thanks in advance!

[far]

anyone know if this is a good deal?
thanks in advance!

This was very unfair to the top
Sunjewels go for ~3 non
Your side consists of the Pink Sorbet that goes for .75 non at most
The added rares don't close that gap.

[Mojokitty]

anyone know if this is a good deal?
thanks in advance!

This was very unfair to the top
Sunjewels go for ~3 non
Your side consists of the Pink Sorbet that goes for .75 non at most
The added rares don't close that gap.

Yes, this is super unfair, almost to the point of scam :,(

[Darth Daddy]

Help please!