The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[XxDragonScalesxX]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97801634&userid=1023233&signature=5oV4OjLwsp4iGePySaBAbA

is this fair? idk if i care about the rats enough

You pet is originally from 2009 and worth a 09 rare. Using the 2:1 method they would be overpaying with a 2010 rare and all the additional pets. So unfair to your trade partner.

You might keep in mind that Malk design pets can get a bit more than their worth and rats tend to have low demand. Up to you if you want to take those into account.

Hi !
I need help with this trade, if anyone has an opinion on it.
Thank you

Overpay on your partners side. The 2020 store pets is worth a mid 2010 rare and you pets is worth a 2011 rare.

I pretty sure they're overpaying but wanted to check if there's some demand for the blue sorb that I don't know about?

this is definitely overpay as the blue balloon and blue sorb would have been a fair swap!

That's what I was thinking. Thank you!

[abbie.]

anyone able to help with these three trades?
thank you in advance!

[XxDragonScalesxX]

anyone able to help with these three trades?
thank you in advance!

I'm pretty sure that dog still follows the 3 month rule which would make it worth 2 09 rares. Going by that all of these trades would be unfair to your trade partner. I would definitely get a second opinion though!

Trade 1 is worth 3 09 rares, a late 2010 rare, and a 2013 uncommon.

Trade 2 worth 2 09 rares and all the uncommons.

Trade 3 is worth 3 09 rares and a late 2010 rare.

[sirenni]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97651465&userid=888853&signature=Bf0YihSVPqUsM23nDTYUdw Hi! I sent this bid to someone but they said it was quite unfair? I thought 2019 store pets got a 2009 pet and I am not aware of any special demand on this pet? Was it really as unfair as they said? thank you in advance!

[Pastel-Axle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97651465&userid=888853&signature=Bf0YihSVPqUsM23nDTYUdw Hi! I sent this bid to someone but they said it was quite unfair? I thought 2019 store pets got a 2009 pet and I am not aware of any special demand on this pet? Was it really as unfair as they said? thank you in advance!

From what I know ‘19 stores go for an early ‘10 rare, and the sloth litter, or it’s PPS don’t experience any additional demand from what I’ve seen. Get a second opinion, but if I’m correct then if anything you’re slightly overpaying.

[XxDragonScalesxX]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97651465&userid=888853&signature=Bf0YihSVPqUsM23nDTYUdw Hi! I sent this bid to someone but they said it was quite unfair? I thought 2019 store pets got a 2009 pet and I am not aware of any special demand on this pet? Was it really as unfair as they said? thank you in advance!

From what I know ‘19 stores go for an early ‘10 rare, and the sloth litter, or it’s PPS don’t experience any additional demand from what I’ve seen. Get a second opinion, but if I’m correct then if anything you’re slightly overpaying.

Agreed.

Depending on how you view pet value right at the start of a new year it could have been worth a late 09 rare but I'd say a 2010 rare since the store pet was released late 2019.

[Ashara]

Does this trade look fair?

[Arcanine Luver]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97651465&userid=888853&signature=Bf0YihSVPqUsM23nDTYUdw Hi! I sent this bid to someone but they said it was quite unfair? I thought 2019 store pets got a 2009 pet and I am not aware of any special demand on this pet? Was it really as unfair as they said? thank you in advance!

From what I know ‘19 stores go for an early ‘10 rare, and the sloth litter, or it’s PPS don’t experience any additional demand from what I’ve seen. Get a second opinion, but if I’m correct then if anything you’re slightly overpaying.

i agree,
overpay on the side of the 09’ rare.

[Ariaa1515]

Just wondering if these are fair trades, thank you in advance

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97759921&userid=1010392&signature=6KbN83Bm4V8ROL5v_mpdPw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97759773&userid=1010392&signature=JYvzptTsr55ElzOvlOa_1Q

[Funkyfandom]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97798518&userid=1004512&signature=aBx3cACBdhLQ01XmZAa53A

is this fair?