The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Spottedleaf16]

Hey y’all, what do you think of this one?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97770969&userid=234404&signature=79lRhI4dlnLMt3Q82y0hUQ

[Rosesguts]

are either of these fair ? they are by the same person

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97771036&userid=1007882&signature=bDi2nsXOaMH0ZgbZTiTVTg

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97771048&userid=1007882&signature=LX2rntLpwaeJ71uowqr5KA

[| nefelibata |]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97756928&userid=985902&signature=IQjsyxdUEc3XHTOSJLW90g

[Rosesguts]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97756928&userid=985902&signature=IQjsyxdUEc3XHTOSJLW90g

[/quote]

I personally would say yes it is a fair trade, the nontag omgsr is directly in the middle of the rares list and its a main list pet that is 12 pets above the cinnabon (if you view it that way) Taking into account for the popularity of the nontag and the warriors it makes up for the rares imo. So yes, it is a fair trade it really just comes down to you and if you want to trade away the cinnabon. I recommend holding onto it though for a possible better offer in your future since some people will really overpay for it. It's demand will only get higher as the years go by as well.

[Guest]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97756928&userid=985902&signature=IQjsyxdUEc3XHTOSJLW90g

I personally would say yes it is a fair trade, the nontag omgsr is directly in the middle of the rares list and its a main list pet that is 12 pets above the cinnabon (if you view it that way) Taking into account for the popularity of the nontag and the warriors it makes up for the rares imo. So yes, it is a fair trade it really just comes down to you and if you want to trade away the cinnabon. I recommend holding onto it though for a possible better offer in your future since some people will really overpay for it. It's demand will only get higher as the years go by as well.

this advice is honestly inaccurate and the placement of the pets do not take demand into account. I suggest you never think of it that way. such as grevys zebra and the nick unicorn are some of the highest pets on horrors list but they are only worth 1n each. their side is only around 1.25n however you can get up to 2n for the cinnamon bun, def not a good trade.

[Spottedleaf16]

Hey y’all, what do you think of this one?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97770969&userid=234404&signature=79lRhI4dlnLMt3Q82y0hUQ

[Pastel-Axle]

Trade 1
Trade 2
Which one of these two offers for my item collection is worth more? I am very tempted by both. I need impressions as soon as possible if that’s okay!

I have taken Trade 1, did I take the better offer?

[Mewfles]

Is this fair?
I’m not used to trading for cs so idk how much the pets are worth

For future reference pets like the bat, the butterfly wolf, the spider, and the last bunny are dec 18 pets they are rereleases of rares from previous years, an easy way to make this easier on yourself is finding the year they were released/and month and naming it that
they are offering a early 11 pet and 100 C$
Your side is a 2012 halloween Bat, a 2008 August BW, a 2011 June Malk Spider, and a 2011 easter bunny, and one extra 2018 bunny
Malk pets have decent demand typically, I'd say the 2011 on their side matches up with the 2011 bunny or spider, however spider may have more demand so lets say the bunny we have a 2008 BW, 2011 Spider, 2018 Bunny, and 2012 bat
Spider can be worth between 20-30 max i'd say the BW is 40~ the bat is roughly 18-21 and the 2018 bunny is 6-8
so at all the higher values its 30+40+21+8= 99
it looks to be about fair ^^ but I'd get a second opinion because malk may have special demand

[Free Shade]

Thoughts on these 2?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97768661&userid=459121&signature=mMVZSAgzvUcQnFZgMKX7bg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97768669&userid=459121&signature=B8En77Y1SIRA3iQVGExHmg

Both for my raven dog though I'm fairly certain the 2nd is unfair?

Thanks for any help!

Also, would an Eat Me be a fair swap for the Raven?
I'm not sure the worth/demand of the two compared to each other

[Pastel-Axle]

Thoughts on these 2?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97768661&userid=459121&signature=mMVZSAgzvUcQnFZgMKX7bg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97768669&userid=459121&signature=B8En77Y1SIRA3iQVGExHmg

Both for my raven dog though I'm fairly certain the 2nd is unfair?

Thanks for any help!

Also, would an Eat Me be a fair swap for the Raven?
I'm not sure the worth/demand of the two compared to each other

The Raven trades for ~5n to my knowledge, and the Eat Me for ~5-5.5. Both trade well from what I’ve seen, so it’s a matter of preference.