The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Toxictoothless]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97746963&userid=997058&signature=j0sVPrSagbzXVLn3HepcoQ

Is this fair ?

[jasmine;]

Is this a fair trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97734698&userid=142226&signature=iQPZtwxsoAeqAheAcUTVBA

Thank you!

[hayzel]

does their side add up to 2ma? thank you in advance!

[ImogenEquine]

please: trades/viewtrade.php?id=97736758&userid=305196&signature=I-6aX25kbCc3oUaj7TZtNg

[Assumed Gender]

is this fair

[admavii]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97723092&userid=985305&signature=U4_VkD1Hbmpu93NWgY7RSw

is this fair?

[Deerdancer]

Is this fair? Involves items. trades/viewtrade.php?id=97729770&userid=203847&signature=kMwjsTOezsZkd9OmspzKaw
and this: trades/viewtrade.php?id=97711156&userid=203847&signature=W9kfCPadC4VHIpPFrsDBzQ

[OakForestFarm006]

is this fair

the water malk cat fetches 0.5ma and the 2011 store gets 1.5-2ma.

what I found about the heavy blue striped was that it was not a list and only worth 3 '09 rares. the valentines malk gets .5ma

the other '10 rares don't really add up on their side.

your side is worth 2-2.5ma while there's can at most be worth about 1ma

unfair to you.

[This Is Halloween]

is this fair

the water malk cat fetches 0.5ma and the 2011 store gets 1.5-2ma.

what I found about the heavy blue striped was that it was not a list and only worth 3 '09 rares. the valentines malk gets .5ma

the other '10 rares don't really add up on their side.

your side is worth 2-2.5ma while there's can at most be worth about 1ma

unfair to you.

Correction, element malk cats are 1MA regardless of whether or not they’re release or true date. 2012 guardian storepets catch a solid 2ma. It is not that hard to search it up.

[qhost]

Could I possibly have some opinions on these trades? I've been out of the trading scene for a few years haha.

One
Two
Three

These two I'm pretty sure are fair swaps, but I'm unsure on demand:

Four
Five

Thankyou! ♥