The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[YellowOrigami]

Can I get some advice on these trades I sent ? Thank you !

Trade 1
Trade 2

trade 1:
marionette trades for 1-2 nons (most steadily at 1.5 nons) (source)
The clear eyed galaxy (CEG) is worth about 1-1.5 non. The Spotted advent is in the sorbet tier and worth about .5 non. Lexi cake dog is a high september and worth about 2 MA (0.25 non). Your side is worth about 1.75 to 2.25 non, so your side is pretty fair.

trade 2:
UR fox is commonly alued at 1.5 nons (source).
the clear eyed galaxy (CEG) is worth about 1-1.5 non. The Spotted advent is in the sorbet tier and worth about .5 non. Lexi cake dog is a high september and worth about 2 MA (0.25 non). The pink moon dog is a low october and worth only about 0.5 MA. Your side is worth roughly 1.25 to 1.75 MA, making the trade about fair.

Feel free to get a second opinion :>

[Helpless]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96537429&userid=745785&signature=eMUaOj6ggSh49K6M7RCuRg is this fair for the banner? i have literally no idea its worth or the worth of my pet

they will both probably end up being uncommon in the end, but right now both have very high demand. I think demand wise the cub may be worth a bit more? I would get a second opinion though

I agree with this. The amount of vampire banner dogs has increased and ever since the lion PPS pets came out, many people have been wanting them. But honestly, I feel like this would be personal preference.

[Nari UwU]

I know the demand for the Banner Dog has calmed down quite a bit, but I've only been doing event swaps so far so I'm really not sure what most of my side is going for
any help appreciated <3

[saküra]

Can I get some advice on these trades I sent ? Thank you !

Trade 1
Trade 2

trade 1:
marionette trades for 1-2 nons (most steadily at 1.5 nons) (source)
The clear eyed galaxy (CEG) is worth about 1-1.5 non. The Spotted advent is in the sorbet tier and worth about .5 non. Lexi cake dog is a high september and worth about 2 MA (0.25 non). Your side is worth about 1.75 to 2.25 non, so your side is pretty fair.

trade 2:
UR fox is commonly alued at 1.5 nons (source).
the clear eyed galaxy (CEG) is worth about 1-1.5 non. The Spotted advent is in the sorbet tier and worth about .5 non. Lexi cake dog is a high september and worth about 2 MA (0.25 non). The pink moon dog is a low october and worth only about 0.5 MA. Your side is worth roughly 1.25 to 1.75 MA, making the trade about fair.

Feel free to get a second opinion :>

It’s actually just the BEG that trades for 1-1.5 n, the CEG is worth 1 n. The ‘08 dog is actually worth 1 MA, I don’t know where you got .5n from and i’m not sure about the cake dog but 2 MA is not .25 n. So their side would just be around 1.25 n. So that’s quite unfair to the other person. The second trade is also unfair to the other person because like I said earlier, the CEG is just worth 1 n so their side would be roughly 1.25 N

[sashiyaki]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96169277&userid=700638&signature=LlMaHM_57HtV11Fgs0R-8A

Hi! Is this fair? Thanks in advance! <3

[Shvlby]

Can I get some advice on these trades I sent ? Thank you !

Trade 1
Trade 2

trade 1:
marionette trades for 1-2 nons (most steadily at 1.5 nons) (source)
The clear eyed galaxy (CEG) is worth about 1-1.5 non. The Spotted advent is in the sorbet tier and worth about .5 non. Lexi cake dog is a high september and worth about 2 MA (0.25 non). Your side is worth about 1.75 to 2.25 non, so your side is pretty fair.

trade 2:
UR fox is commonly alued at 1.5 nons (source).
the clear eyed galaxy (CEG) is worth about 1-1.5 non. The Spotted advent is in the sorbet tier and worth about .5 non. Lexi cake dog is a high september and worth about 2 MA (0.25 non). The pink moon dog is a low october and worth only about 0.5 MA. Your side is worth roughly 1.25 to 1.75 MA, making the trade about fair.

Feel free to get a second opinion :>

It’s actually just the BEG that trades for 1-1.5 n, the CEG is worth 1 n. The ‘08 dog actually is just 1 MA, I don’t know where you got .5n from and i’m not sure about the cake dog but 2 MA is not .25 n. So their side would just be around 1.25 n. So that’s quite unfair to the other person. The second trade is also unfair to the other person because like I said earlier, the CEG is just worth 1 n so their side would be roughly 1.25 N

Hi! I would just like to agree with saküra - The CEG and BEG typically trade for 1-1.5 nons (currently I see people valuing them more around 1 non, however there are a lot of trades valuing it @1.5 nons) The Pale Spotted Advent is an Advent and only worth 1 MA (with it being true-date however, it can possibly be valued around 1.5-2 MAs) The Marionette as of currently is being valued more around 2 nons, very rarely are people valuing it around 1.5 nons in the current market!

The first trade I would argue is unfair to the marionette by about .25 nons give or take, valuing your side at it's highest (1.75 nons)

The second trade really depends on how you both value all the pets - If you value the CEG @1.5 nons it's unfair to you. If you value the CEG @1 non it's unfair to the fox!

Other Sources used:
UR Fox Lexi Cake Dog

[Arcanine Luver]

i think this is unfair to me but im not sure due to the value of the horse

any help would be greatly appreciated!

[ChunkyChad]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96510029&userid=381346&signature=MGMpH0rGX02No0PSowesPA

Hi does anyone know the values of each side? my brain is fried from midterms so i'm struggling to do the math lol

[Arcanine Luver]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96510029&userid=381346&signature=MGMpH0rGX02No0PSowesPA

Hi does anyone know the values of each side? my brain is fried from midterms so i'm struggling to do the math lol

The warrior cat and zodiac dogs are valued a lot higher than the wolves! (edit here, checked the what is this pet worth thread and this is what i came up with) the wolves typically trade for the 3 month rule whereas the warrior alone is around.5 MA (and sometimes 1 MA if true date with demand) so this is majorly unfair to you!

[Lluca]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96539955&userid=273739&signature=O8mQef2WZ2sd3V-Nvso2YA

How is this? I have no idea when it comes to items...