The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Ruruskadoo]

I know this trade is item heavy but I'd be really grateful if someone could give me advice on it, thanks in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97038730&userid=119355&signature=OioIOjMvSsxLfEW5-EJm9g


I'm assuming this will be fairly straightforward even though my other trade is complicated, I just never remember what store pets are worth. Is this one fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97054259&userid=119355&signature=-JZ_CMPXeRM6VRLDAYfBFA

[Lanayru]

I'm awful w C$ - is this fair to me? If not what should be added/removed to make it fair? tysm!

[I’m Bored]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97057563&userid=938674&signature=qK6bcTTOjv41vRfL59CRxQ

Im not very good with my rares so could someone help me with this? Is it fair? If not what could be added/changed to make it fair

Heya, as it stand the Ur Holly Dog is worth a minimum of 1 non which is anything from 100 to 150 2009 rare’s, value wise that trade is major over pay ur side. I’d try to work out the exact value but the items are as far as I am aware just random one with no specific values other than being worth an uncommon each at the very least, from their year of release and the pets themselves I doubt round up to more than .25 non just taking a quick glance if u follow the 2:1 trade up/down ration.

I would get another opinion on the items as I’m not very sure as to which may be worth more than an uncommon from their year of release. They could be worth more to horse collectors it’s all about finding the right ppl to take items at their worth.

Subjectivity speaking I don’t think their side is equal in value to your Holly Dog.

[nicole]

is this fair?

And this one, I don't know how much these Items are woth

Both of these trades are unfair to you. The first trade is worth 2 MAs and their side is at least like what.. 5 09 rares? (4 for both cats and 1 09 rare for the 50c$.) Your side is like 16 09 rares.

The second trade contains items older than 2021 so they would need uncommons that are from the same year as they were released. For example, the 'Cow Figurine' was released in 2013 so it's worth a 2013 uncommon. A 2021 uncommon/rare is extremely unfair to it.

[vehk]

what would i need to add to a tan (?) basilisk + 200 c$ to be fair for a yellow toxic

[Rojii]

Is this fair ?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97060207&userid=990402&signature=mzsh0gSDzZYDUu-x_uP30A

[sapphirelion]

Is this fair ?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97060207&userid=990402&signature=mzsh0gSDzZYDUu-x_uP30A

Your pet is in the archive from October 2008, this is very unfair to you.

I'm awful w C$ - is this fair to me? If not what should be added/removed to make it fair? tysm!

It really depends on what you and your trade partner consider each pet/rarity to be worth.
Here is a guide with a few variations of c$ worth’s of just uncommon pets

is this fair? seems good to me just wanted to double check with someone (cause I'm terrible with knowing item values)

thank you in advance

edit: opinions on this as well would be appreciated! (neither of us know how much the wings are worth)

Trade 1:
This trade is unfair to your trade partner. Your item is from this year’s Cave Event (summer event) making it only worth about a 2021 uncommon. Using the 2:1 rule on the year difference, your side is only worth about a 2018 uncommon
(2 2021 uncommons= 1 2020 uncommon + 3 2020 uncommons= 4 2020 uncommons/2= 2 2019 uncommons/2= 1 2018 uncommon)


Trade 2: items are generally worth an uncommon from the same year the item released, in this case 2013.

Even without the rare on your side, this trade would be unfair to you

[WildCreeps]

Hello everyone!

I have a dilemma.... someone sent me this trade and Im not sure what to do...

Please tell me if its fair or over etc..

AND also what I could get from the Lolita

[nicole]

Hello everyone!

I have a dilemma.... someone sent me this trade and Im not sure what to do...

Please tell me if its fair or over etc..

AND also what I could get from the Lolita

Wrong link. Make sure to copy and paste the link at the bottom of the trade, not the URL at the top of the page c:

[Quackers <3]

Can I have some input on this trade? I am not too keen on trading the BMD at this time, however am fairly interested in the Lolita.
Thanks!