The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[HaleighSB]

Would 3 zebras and UR peas be worth the UR cat?

depends on the zebras offered.
the ur sitting cat is going for 2.5-3n
a vr zebra is 0.75, the omgsr zebra is 1n

so 3 vr zebras would be 2.25n + the peas would be 2.75n
2 vr zebra + 1 omgsr zebra + peas would be 3n
so both would be fair
only 2 omsr zebras + 1 vr + ur peas would be overpay for the ur cat

Thank you. Can I get one more additional opinion?

1000% agree with godking's heretic. We cant really give you a straight answer unless we know which zebras we're talking about, but everything they said previously is correct

[Delest Wolf]

Trade 1
Trade 2

Are either of these fair?

[Geckos_N_Tea]

would this be fair?
im not too sure how much the roba rat is worth especially since there isn’t much trade data, they say it’s worth 1.5-3 ma which i wouldn’t doubt. thank you in advance for any help! <3

[Nero1007]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97037518&userid=1007517&signature=WVt5pR0kOeereqq6ZJR0sA
Is this trade better?

[HaleighSB]

would this be fair?
im not too sure how much the roba rat is worth especially since there isn’t much trade data, they say it’s worth 1.5-3 ma which i wouldn’t doubt. thank you in advance for any help! <3

The worth on the green robo rat is still heavily debated (source) but I think most have come to the general consensus of 0.5-1ma (someone feel free to fact check me on this). Despire the rat's value though, this is unfair to you as your 2011 store is 2 MA (source) and since the robo rat is 1ma at most, they're under by about 1ma.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97037518&userid=1007517&signature=WVt5pR0kOeereqq6ZJR0sA
Is this trade better?

Still very unfair to you. You have 2 older uncommons (2012 and 2015) that their side oesn't add up to using the 2:1 rule. You could probably do 4 of their 2021 commons for your 2020 uncommon though.

Trade 1
Trade 2

Are either of these fair?

Sorry, I can't give great advice on the first trade. As far as the second trade, your side is under by 1 09 rare. The gray BC is 1MA, and your pets add up to the following:

x3 16 stores = 3 09 rares
x1 17 store = 1 09 rare
x6 2020/2021 stores = 6 '10 rares/3 09 rares
Total: 7 09 rares.

[Alayra]

Hello!

Can anyone help me with this trade please:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97048069&userid=531483&signature=Kgd3CeAVyafub59q8mB78g

Thank you!

[Sali]

Please help c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97052826&userid=273533&signature=IWKtHAOqW34MkZkrnG-Vfg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97054685&userid=273533&signature=PYbIp-S-QdOvvchvPxVNWA

[Valak]

is this fair for green toxic. is green toxic in demand

[Magdalenka]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97055244&userid=816951&signature=w4VXkdVhOZjKEpGgbgxXJQ

Hi, could you please tell me if this trade is fair? I have a feeling it's not, I think that doggie is quite valuable, but I wanted to get the opinion of someone who knows better. Thanks!

[HaleighSB]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97055244&userid=816951&signature=w4VXkdVhOZjKEpGgbgxXJQ

Hi, could you please tell me if this trade is fair? I have a feeling it's not, I think that doggie is quite valuable, but I wanted to get the opinion of someone who knows better. Thanks!

Yes, this is greatly unfair to you. They're short ~0.5-1n
Your side:
- UR Holly: 1-1.5n (source)

Their side:
**Note: I'm ignoring the UC and under pets as they don't contribute much to value in this case
- Red-fronted Holly: 1.25ma
- Blue shadow cat: Little trade data, but likely ~0.5MA
- Line tribal: 0.25n
- Tricolor cake dog: 2MA
- x4 2017 stores: 4 09 rares/0.5 MA
- 2013 store: 1 MA
Total: 0.25n + 5.25MA which comes to the lower side of ~0.5n
- 2014 store: ~0.75 MA
(Source to the above: what is this pet worth thread and horror's list.