The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Highland]

Just wanna make sure that this is good

[Halsie]

Is this trade fair for my pps roadkill?

[Taro_Queen]

Is this fair to the TD full Zodiac set?

I feel that there side is overpay, two lists, a 2012 Alien Storepet, and two warriors

Personally have seen full set of Zodiac go for about a non worth of pets... '12 Alien Store pet is about 1MA, a ex-list tess horse I believe is still going for 1MA and added up the rest (taken into consideration that warrior cats are going for about 3 '09 rares, and not sure of any other special value of the rest of the pets) about 15 '09 rares or 1.5 MA. Altogether I see about 3.5MA, which I believe is unfair to you. This is my opinion, please feel free to get a second opinion.

Anyone want to give a second opinion?

[jerky]

Just wanna make sure that this is good

i replied to the other side of this trade earlier! i believe it’s over on their side.

[Highland]

Just wanna make sure that this is good

i replied to the other side of this trade earlier! i believe it’s over on their side.

It was edited a tad since then^^

[Deerdancer]

Is this fair? Involves an older pet for a handful of newer pets.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97021217&userid=203847&signature=1Dfezigd-Fn0V37PnJG0oA
and this:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97021331&userid=203847&signature=SaFzAqyIG1K-MBwfrHMIGw

[Arcanine Luver]

Hello! i know its kind of a lot to ask, but i was wondering if anyone would tell me which bid on my store dogs has the best value for me? or maybe if i might be better off not taking either bid?

Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5

these bids all seem similar in value to me!
any help is appreciated

[deeer]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97023525&userid=647810&signature=GiF37jIwdhFEjZ5tEiXS3g
Thoughts? These are like all of my rarest pets so I'm not sure if I want to give away them all in one trade

[Lee-Sins]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97023525&userid=647810&signature=GiF37jIwdhFEjZ5tEiXS3g
Thoughts? These are like all of my rarest pets so I'm not sure if I want to give away them all in one trade

So the banana tends to get 1N.
The TD BMD would be 1N or more.

Demand wise - you'd be better off keeping your dogs IMO.
Banana's are terrible to trade off unless you'd like to take a huge loss, or all C$.

[deeer]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97023525&userid=647810&signature=GiF37jIwdhFEjZ5tEiXS3g
Thoughts? These are like all of my rarest pets so I'm not sure if I want to give away them all in one trade

So the banana tends to get 1N.
The TD BMD would be 1N or more.

Demand wise - you'd be better off keeping your dogs IMO.

Thank you!