The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[jasparry7]

Can someone help me with this please? It’s items and pets and I’m not too good with worth/fairness. Thank you in advance for your help! x

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97020583&userid=989316&signature=AE6ycW9uXimGvAmONcSIqw

I think its unfair to you as the 2013 store pet, but it depends how much you value the element malk cats and the store pets

Thank you, can I have a second opinion please?

[Halsie]

Is this trade fair for my pps roadkill?

[Taro_Queen]

Is this fair to the TD full Zodiac set?

I feel that there side is overpay, two lists, a 2012 Alien Storepet, and two warriors

Personally have seen full set of Zodiac go for about a non worth of pets... '12 Alien Store pet is about 1MA, a ex-list tess horse I believe is still going for 1MA and added up the rest (taken into consideration that warrior cats are going for about 3 '09 rares, and not sure of any other special value of the rest of the pets) about 15 '09 rares or 1.5 MA. Altogether I see about 3.5MA, which I believe is unfair to you. This is my opinion, please feel free to get a second opinion.

Okay! Wow I had no idea that the full set would go for a whole non! Thank you so much! Anyone want to give a second opinion?

[cloven]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97020883&userid=919435&signature=eM8TquX39hVCOE91Txd8ng

Just curious about this trade for my peach auction! Don’t know the demand for the malk nowadays!

[dry]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97020925&userid=830020&signature=Vx6Ou6s-qslKNRwbqoD7gw
is this fair?

[jerky]

Can someone help me with this please? It’s items and pets and I’m not too good with worth/fairness. Thank you in advance for your help! x

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97020583&userid=989316&signature=AE6ycW9uXimGvAmONcSIqw

from just a quick look, your valentines malk dog is about .5MA, the 2013 store pet is around a low advents worth. the light, dark, and earth dragons go for an 09 rare each i believe. their malk elemental cats are about .5 MA each (3-4 ‘09 rares)
and the warrior cats are 3-4 ‘09 rares each. the bulk rares and items on your side adds up to much more than their side.

[Swerenity]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97020933&userid=900112&signature=wOBvm96XUQKcmJrsjClapA

what does the hollyfox go for demand wise?

[AddyBoo77]

Is this fair? I’m not good with the worth of items -any help is appreciated!

[Flicka]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97012776&userid=9355&signature=b-IN7gTnJWlocBdCZvWcEg is this fair?

[Deerdancer]

Is this fair? Involves an older pet for a handful of newer pets.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97021217&userid=203847&signature=1Dfezigd-Fn0V37PnJG0oA
and this:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97021331&userid=203847&signature=SaFzAqyIG1K-MBwfrHMIGw