The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Cady55again]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96982045&userid=973739&signature=QMNjRYROKxoIXdsainIDTw
this fair?

i need help with this please

PLZ

[Valak]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96982045&userid=973739&signature=QMNjRYROKxoIXdsainIDTw
this fair?

i need help with this please

PLZ

hi cady, they are overpaying, usually a store pet im not sure how much exactly but its worth usually from am 11' rare to a 09' rare the newer store pets being worth closer to an 11' but still they are overpaying

[walks223]

hi!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=96982614&userid=394620&signature=n18LngWHmh_PiMP6uxKeFQ
how would this need to be edited to be fair? what are the pet's values?

[reynard]

I have two trades I'd like opinions on if someone is willing.

Trade One I have already been told is unfair to the bottom - does anyone know what I could remove in order to make it more fair?

Trade Two involves store pets so I am big lost haha.

Thank you in advance :)

[Deoledath]

I have two trades I'd like opinions on if someone is willing.

-Snip because not sure-

Trade Two involves store pets so I am big lost haha.

Thank you in advance

Your 2014 store pets are worth around 2 '09 rares + 1 '10 rare per pet and they are offering 1 early-'09 rerelease VR and 1 mid-'09 rerelease VR -- I'd say it's about fair, if not a tad unfair to you, but I recommend getting a 2nd opinion since I'm still new to rarity math and I'm unsure of the value difference between a R and a VR

[little34511]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96980680&userid=655071&signature=5I-nT2_DQDHv9HE44Q3Rcw
unsure of list value help

[Shvlby]

I have two trades I'd like opinions on if someone is willing.

-Snip because not sure-

Trade Two involves store pets so I am big lost haha.

Thank you in advance

Your 2014 store pets are worth around 2 '09 rares + 1 '10 rare per pet and they are offering 1 early-'09 rerelease VR and 1 mid-'09 rerelease VR -- I'd say it's about fair, if not a tad unfair to you, but I recommend getting a 2nd opinion since I'm still new to rarity math and I'm unsure of the value difference between a R and a VR

Hi! I actually would have to disagree - 2014 store pets currently are going around .5 of an MA (so about 3-4 2009 rares each, give or take), not to mention the Sakura Store Dog has good demand and could potentially fetch up to 1 MA. This would be unfair to the store pets!

(Also for regular rare / very rare differences most people use the 2 to 1 rule, which just means that one very rare = two rares from the same year!)

[Jelloskello]

Hello! So my trading partner and I aren't sure about the values on the store pets, so any advice on what to remove/add to make this fair would be very appreciated.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96978104&userid=993463&signature=DfS53dgJqsyO_X5jHIQ1JQ

Thank you!

[Valak]

Hello! So my trading partner and I aren't sure about the values on the store pets, so any advice on what to remove/add to make this fair would be very appreciated.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96978104&userid=993463&signature=DfS53dgJqsyO_X5jHIQ1JQ

Thank you!

this is definetly an overpay.

[Assumed Gender]

Hello! So my trading partner and I aren't sure about the values on the store pets, so any advice on what to remove/add to make this fair would be very appreciated.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96978104&userid=993463&signature=DfS53dgJqsyO_X5jHIQ1JQ

Thank you!

this is definetly an overpay.

i 2nd that, the side with all the old rares is overpaying