The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[chaoticaura]

Hi would this be considered fair please?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96903495&userid=684364&signature=-9RIlvMcPesyxUPOFcl-nQ

Stores confuse me, thanks for any help!

A full set of store pets currently being sold is 70c$. Technically this is fair but since I’m pretty sure the black cat is part of the warriors litter (please correct me if I am wrong!), the other person is overpaying if you include demand in with the pet.

[ChillyKitty]

I'm rusty with rares, and I'm not sure if a pet being a dragon affects anything? thoughts? Thanks in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96903008&userid=707506&signature=-tjifDTlvm8balHbO28dzg

[joop]

I'm rusty with rares, and I'm not sure if a pet being a dragon affects anything? thoughts? Thanks in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96903008&userid=707506&signature=-tjifDTlvm8balHbO28dzg

that's unfair to you, their side doesn't equal a 2015 rare. if you use the 2:1 rule that would equal 1 2018 rare at most

[nicole]

Hi would this be considered fair please?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96903495&userid=684364&signature=-9RIlvMcPesyxUPOFcl-nQ

Stores confuse me, thanks for any help!

This is fair to both sides considering they're valuing the warrior cat at 2 09 rares, and then the other 2011 rare while your side would be 2 09 rares (valuing four of them at a 2010 rare each) and then the last one at a 2011 rare, as 2021 store pets are worth a early 2011 rare to late 2010 rare. It's up to you on which side you prefer.

[Spring Storm]

Not sure if I'm going to accept or not but I am curious if I do think of accepting if this would be a fair offer for the brown carousel horse?

Thank you for your help!

[Scary Blood]

My Trading Knowledge got really rusty on Hiatus especially with List Trades, can someone please help me out with this Trade?

[joop]

not sure about this one, i would appreciate some help
-edit - i feel like i'm underpaying but i don't know what the total worth is of either pets

[Geckos_N_Tea]

i believe this is unfair to me but i would just like to make sure. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96910504&userid=900146&signature=51WFS3vF-kUIDdnaPsdGVA

[do.ggo]

Are these two trades fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96751204&userid=123051&signature=cIye8zrWOEgxUl2EEXbzMg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96888870&userid=123051&signature=epRXS8W2CwYkvw6Bqu7DiQ

[Akila]

Can someone please help me with this list trade?

I checked the 'new' condensed rarity list and the explanation and examples of the tiers and trades.
If i got it right, the sorbet buns go up and down a lot and are worth around a mid advent because of it..?
The spider seems to be a high september and goes for more at times.. so I think I'm overpaying a bit, even considering that spiders have a lower demand..? o:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96911111&userid=251473&signature=FuMzVcsJ_TzBlUzGY3sQ2A