The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[S0fte]

i'm a bit confused, would they be underpaying since mine is a 2015 and theirs is a 2016?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96015176&userid=1023164&signature=7XAyWSXcwXUjGw_9RYo4kQ

yes they would be underpaying, they would need to add another 2016 uncommon for it to be fair

thank you! i'm gonna try sort smth out with them now that i know that ^^

[Ninjessa]

Got a big trade... I wonder why they are trying to get rid of it? But anyhow, I've been gone for a while and want to know if this is fair at all. I'm also not sure how easy it is to trade this off currently , please let me know

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96012166&userid=19756&signature=W7wEjiUhaH5KPDJMRBG-jQ

[DarkMerlin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96014848&userid=1767&signature=k1NSpVK7D1kVyGEwCFTKzg

Is this fair?
2010 store dog for these?

[Lee-Sins]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96014848&userid=1767&signature=k1NSpVK7D1kVyGEwCFTKzg

Is this fair?
2010 store dog for these?

Extremely unfair to the green Android dog (the 2010 store dog). The green Android is worth a non dog.
One non is worth 10-14MAs or 80-130 ‘09 rares.

[DarkMerlin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96014848&userid=1767&signature=k1NSpVK7D1kVyGEwCFTKzg

Is this fair?
2010 store dog for these?

Extremely unfair to the green Android dog (the 2010 store dog). The green Android is worth a non dog.
One non is worth 10-14MAs or 80-130 ‘09 rares.

Ok thank you!

[EchothroughDarkness]

Just want to check this trade.
So is it fair to both sides?
I'm sure I have my numbers correct.
Trade

[Syn_cat]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=96015343&userid=737315&signature=Ogua5H-GNNa0LWVwF_QheA

[rix]

I just got this bid in my auction. I'm not too good with items, so is this fair?
(Click)
Thank you so, so much to anyone who finds time to help!!

[angelberry]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96013871&userid=121954&signature=4vN8eAaOxL9UuVfdMAByvw

i really need help with this one! thanks : )

[saküra]

I just got this bid in my auction. I'm not too good with items, so is this fair?
(Click)
Thank you so, so much to anyone who finds time to help!!

the plushies are from christmas of 2013 and i’d say they’re probably worth a 2013 common each(i may be wrong) i don’t know about the other items but either way i think this is a good bid. the october ‘08 dog is worth .5 MA and the tess dragon is worth 2’09 rares i think plus a ‘10 rare so that’d be 5.5-6 ‘09 rares on their side. so if you value your zodiac dogs at 2-3 ‘09 rares each then this is a good trade. if you value them at 4 then i wouldn’t take it but i never see people value them at 4. they’re usually valued at 3. You may want a second opinion

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96013871&userid=121954&signature=4vN8eAaOxL9UuVfdMAByvw

i really need help with this one! thanks : )

they are overpaying. they didn’t have to add because the 2017 store lion is already enough for both of those because your side adds up to an ‘09 rare. the rest is just overpay