The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[NARKOTIKA]

Hello! Is this fair? I'm very unsure on the demand of the horse, and although the rat hasn't got great demand it's an OMGSR so it's a little more attractive.

Thank you so much for your help!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95557565&userid=820246&signature=Vys6qohvJY9popFOw4T15w

Still need help please <3

[Olívía]

can i get an opinion on 2 separate bids for my DIY Cake Set? which would you choose? all pets on the second bid are on my wishlist if that matters. :) thank you!
bid 1
bid 2

[darkspawn]

hi is this fair?
Thanks in advance!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95558102&userid=634043&signature=YWFZvdVvkohAiI35DaTLyg

[The BadWolf]

Is this fair (especially demand-wise)? I'm utterly abysmal when it comes to huge trades.

[espvespeon]

Is this fair (especially demand-wise)? I'm utterly abysmal when it comes to huge trades.

Edit : Was falsely informed on the value of the moonswirl, my apologies ^^|

[batman...]

Is this fair (especially demand-wise)? I'm utterly abysmal when it comes to huge trades.

This isn’t fair to you at all, demand-wise nor fairness-wise

The Moonswirl has a pretty decent demand and fetches between 4-5 nons I believe, meanwhile their trade barely fetches 1.5/2, and the demand isn’t very good for the overall trade itself either ^^

Please done give false information!
The moonswirl only goes for 2-2.5 nons more so commonly traded for 2 nons as they are harder to trade off.

Please get a second opinion as I’m unaware what their side is worth but the moonswirl is no where near worth 4-5 nons

Again only worth 2-2.5 nons

[The BadWolf]

Thank you all so very much for the help!

[Leek.dot]

[color=#000080]How about this one?
I am not good with rarities so any help would be amazing, thank you![/color]

[Mishi23]

Hi!
Is this trade fair? Could I get more for the Malk Dog?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95546161&userid=51301&signature=6op2V9VYc88MH9iUB6uakQ

[musicgurl333]

Hi!
Is this trade fair? Could I get more for the Malk Dog?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95546161&userid=51301&signature=6op2V9VYc88MH9iUB6uakQ

I would definitely accept if it was me. Malks do tend to have higher than average demand, but this pup was only uncommon up until fairly recently, so it's not as hard to find as some older rares.

Going by the typical store pet values, it's about fair. However, store pets trade easily and you could likely retrade the fox for more without any problems.