The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Ice_Dragon]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95538881&userid=783020&signature=MPusHUhwLhRd43XsuL9vvA

is this fair?

[JustDucky]

How does this trade look?

I rlly like the pet on my side but I'm willing to look at trades if it's fair

I believe they are overpaying. They offered a 2010 rare, and your pet is only worth the 3 month rule.

[Neoncherry64]

How does this trade look?

I rlly like the pet on my side but I'm willing to look at trades if it's fair

I believe they are overpaying. They offered a 2010 rare, and your pet is only worth the 3 month rule.

While that pet is technically worth the 3 month rule, its demand is crazy high. All my trades offering the three month rule for this pet have been declined. Every time someone auctions one, the bids are always way more than the pet’s actual worth. While auctions are definitely not the best way to judge pet worth, it would be wrong of me not to mention past auction results. It is up to you how much, if any overpay you are looking for, as demand is always up to the individual traders.

[DarkMerlin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95549046&userid=1767&signature=J9hJkRub_eRoX1DmRIUkWg

Is this fair? I am not sure of the value worth of those items.

all those items I'm pretty sure you can purchase in the c$ store, so ig it's up to whether you want to buy them or trade for them

Thanks!

[beantrio]

is this fair? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95548747&userid=1018858&signature=oT5qky9djhKyWHQFxd9Xqw

[FrostbitenRoses]

Is this fair? I don't know what items are worth
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95503051&userid=661506&signature=3B0sm9LsPLphHfNGVGLomA

[Olívía]

can i get an opinion on 2 separate bids for my DIY Cake Set? which would you choose? all pets on the second bid are on my wishlist if that matters. :) thank you!
bid 1
bid 2

[Geckos_N_Tea]

is this fair? keeping in mind species and list demand. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95542795&userid=900146&signature=iInocCAHekGb7xZ63WctdA

i’ve asked on multiple pages any help appreciated! <3

[Aryastelle]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95551270&userid=1012917&signature=plE0IaUzKh-b6E82zqwx5Q

I'm unsure about this one and the other person's eems unsure too lol but I personally don't feel it's ✨great✨ for me

[Hiraeth.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95551270&userid=1012917&signature=plE0IaUzKh-b6E82zqwx5Q

I'm unsure about this one and the other person's eems unsure too lol but I personally don't feel it's ✨great✨ for me

Unfair to you a 2020 rare is worth 4 2020 uncommons, it's unlikely for the unknown cat to be anymore than an uncommon