The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Pastel-Axle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95545299&userid=788082&signature=wF4iTjuggfo5errvGOJ-LQ

Is this fair?

I don’t think so. The grey and red dragons are generally valued at 0.25 nons each, and I don’t think that the other trader’s pets reach that.

[apricott]

Is this fair for the both og us?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95545811&userid=273739&signature=L2E1nwWPGV0KZ461MtKw6g

it's a 2012 halloween item, so i'd say that you're overpaying by the years, but getting a second opinion would be best

[Rookspirit]

please help trades/viewtrade.php?id=95546017&userid=762403&signature=PDnVrLN35Pt4wnv5tmKuLg

[draculauraaa]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95545988&userid=899291&signature=Zzw1pSCfiElOnrf_0utFgw
I know this wasnt fair because the horse is a 2009, but about how much is it worth? like 2 '09 rares? i dont think they realized it was a rerelease bcuz i say to ignore names but i dont know how rarities work anymore dawg

[Morningstar0808]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95542784&userid=378977&signature=yMkXc8KJmjJl9nFjQL6FBg

Is this fair? Also could someone update me on the value of this dog? I haven't been on CS much recently but have been getting a ton of offers for this dog that seem like huge overpay so I'm a little confused

[Pastel-Axle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95542784&userid=378977&signature=yMkXc8KJmjJl9nFjQL6FBg

Is this fair? Also could someone update me on the value of this dog? I haven't been on CS much recently but have been getting a ton of offers for this dog that seem like huge overpay so I'm a little confused

They are overpaying. The pet’s just a normal 2021 rare, it’s just in high demand at the moment due to its status as a rare monthly adopt.

[draculauraaa]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95546039&userid=899291&signature=7dm8gZMSndWXlFwYEN6kKA
should i take this? i love the pets and all the items they want are doubles so i wouldnt mind trading them off, i just dont know if its fair or not lol

[moonviewing]

is this fair? i dont know when either of the items are from

[ηιgнтѕнα∂σω]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95546049&userid=365355&signature=B-Hjn8tvrP79E5ZWAm2EOQ Fair?

[yandere]

is this fair? i dont know when either of the items are from

they are offering a 2013 slumber party item for your 2020 halloween item, so i'd say it's overpay on their side!