The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Geckos_N_Tea]

Hi, is this fair for both sides?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95528576&userid=667686&signature=TtI-f2Vcyye4kj1BEkeS1A

Thank you for any help!

i’m pretty sure you’re over because i think the vr dog is worth a few ‘09 rares which makes their side under, i may be wrong though

imo their side is under. they’ve offered store pets which have a total combined value of a 2009 rare plus a 2011 rare. they’ve also offered 35c$ which i’d say with the 2011 rare should be about a 2009 rare. and they’ve also offered a 2009 rare dog. so that’s about 3x 2009 rares on their side. your side i believe is more than that. just the 2x ‘10 dogs + 2x ‘09 rare dogs would cover the store pets and 2009 rare on their side. however they’ve also added a couple recent rares and older uncommons to their side. so i would say keep 2 ‘10 uncommon bw on your side plus the 2x ‘10 rares and 2x ‘09 rares, should make this trade fair. i would seek more advice tho! <3

[Geckos_N_Tea]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95529461&userid=900146&signature=Muv7XUl9Ve7MB6K7VilF_A

fair?

[Constellation.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95528884&userid=72123&signature=wTHJdXbvSNl-WaRgFfR9hA

Is this fair?

Based on the OMGSR/VR Successful Trades Thread, the UR Malk has been going for 1.5 nons. The rerelease BA has been going for 1 non, and 1000 has (in the past) been the minimum baseline for 0.5 nons but it appears that C$ values currently are on the rise and the baseline may be 1200 C$ currently, I'd get a second opinion on that though!

[CoffeeEX]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95528535&userid=881679&signature=jgYsQg79K2eX_wO6Z9GdIg

howdy, how was this trade? ty for any help <3

[GoldieDoggy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95528515&userid=949727&signature=mspXErKqAHMxUiuNxa78mQ is this fair?

[Geckos_N_Tea]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95529461&userid=900146&signature=Muv7XUl9Ve7MB6K7VilF_A

fair?

[tigres2003]

Hi, is this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95528332&userid=668206&signature=hI7QlZTwyKakESQKTacI3w

[Neoncherry64]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95529461&userid=900146&signature=Muv7XUl9Ve7MB6K7VilF_A

fair?

I’d say this is pretty fair. Cheshire Cat trades for 2 mid advents (occasionally a little bit more), and the alien store dog trades for one. The WWA goes for .25 nons (3-4 mid advents) so it seems to check out. It’s worth noting also that even though the side with the stores is only 3 MA, the fact that they’re stores and won’t be re-released can bump up the value and desirability for some traders.

Hi, is this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95528332&userid=668206&signature=hI7QlZTwyKakESQKTacI3w

I’d say this is unfair to you, I would highly advise you to keep your stores. They have very good demand/tradeability, and c$ is a pain to trade off nowadays and has been steadily declining in value.

[Emi_]

this? It looks like it's a pretty fair 1:1 swap, but I can't find much info on how much the Phoenix has been going for recently.

[Neoncherry64]

this? It looks like it's a pretty fair 1:1 swap, but I can't find much info on how much the Phoenix has been going for recently.

If you and your trade partner value both pets at 1.5 nons, this could be fair. I might hold off on this trade or ask them to add a bit, though, as the strawberry goes for the high end of 1-1.5 nons, while the Phoenix goes for 1.5 to 2 nons. The last successful trade for the UR Phoenix in the trade thread was posted in February, so it isn’t too recent. But it was for a dogtag, which can trade for 2 nons. I’d definitely get a second opinion on this as well, as I also can’t find much recent data on the Phoenix.