The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[zeedie]

hello! would this trade be fair?

[Vaal Hazak]

not sure if this trade (https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95450319&userid=29135&signature=ApTzQ-2wTxtJ5Jr5UG3LVA) is fair. I can't find an updated list tier breakdown, so not sure if that's still even a thing (I was more active on the site when it was last updated, lol).

**edit: could someone also link me an updated list when they respond w/ advice, if that exists? need to bookmark it. thanks in advance!

A rr banana is going for 1n, the Cake Dog is 2 ma and the vr Zebra is 0.75n - 1n. Depending on how you value the vr Zebra this trade is either fair (lower end of 1n) or unfair to the Zebra's side.

[Howl's Moving Castle]

Is this fair?
What is my side worth? It has been so long since trading old stores that I have no idea
What does the diy cake set in full usually go for?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95445995&userid=403103&signature=3lb3muYhb-rQ9bvzaRdscA

you're over, each pet you have is 1.5-2 nons, the cake DIY set tends to get 2.5-3.5 from looking around on trade threads. also just store pets have a high demand i would personally rather take pets vs. items

[batman...]

Hi is this fair
They value the corgis as 1.5 nons for 6 of them.. I’ve only ever seen them go for a mid advent each so I’m just making sure this is fair as I do adore them <3

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95452133&userid=401632&signature=YL-Vwi0bNnls5PKtLMXidw

[nicole]

Is this fair?
What is my side worth? It has been so long since trading old stores that I have no idea
What does the diy cake set in full usually go for?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95445995&userid=403103&signature=3lb3muYhb-rQ9bvzaRdscA

Marionette fetches 1.5-2n and Patchwork is a steady 1.5n, so your side would be 3-3.5n. The entire cake set goes for about 3-4n as it's hard to come across, especially for trade. This is fair to both parties.

Hi is this fair
They value the corgis as 1.5 nons for 6 of them.. I’ve only ever seen them go for a mid advent each so I’m just making sure this is fair as I do adore them <3

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95452133&userid=401632&signature=YL-Vwi0bNnls5PKtLMXidw

Corgis are 1 MA, the 2011 horses are 2 MA each, and the bat dog + red x pps are 2 MAs so their side is 16 MAs. So about 1.5n as 10 MAs equals a non and a sorb is worth 5-7 MAs. Your side is 2.5-3n so it's unfair to you!


Edit: I wanted to clarify that both RR Batdog and Red X PPS are both 2 MAs each so it would be 4 MAs in total, not that the both of them are 1 MA each and it's 2 MAs in total, but either way it's still completely unfair to you!


Correction: Red X PPS is actually 2.5-3 MAs rereleased but on the sake of this trade I'll be valuing it at 2.5 MAs

[CoffeeEX]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95452530&userid=881679&signature=LBD2eSeN_ekQ3xzJiEEoaw

not sure if this is fair? they said they value the cheshire at 2 ma but i thought it was around .5n? any help would be greatly appreciated <3

[zealouss]

Hi! Is this fair? Thank you in advance!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95426559&userid=1002109&signature=_BS3RaJiNyUqGtqjXStyAw

:,)

[Sweetfrog]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95452530&userid=881679&signature=LBD2eSeN_ekQ3xzJiEEoaw

not sure if this is fair? they said they value the cheshire at 2 ma but i thought it was around .5n? any help would be greatly appreciated <3

The Cheshire goes for .25-.5 nons it just seems to depend on the trading partners, but looking at the successful trade thread I’d say you can get .5 for it alone with the right person and I wouldn’t trade it for 2 ma
Forum/search.php?keywords=Cheshire+&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

[Vaal Hazak]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95452530&userid=881679&signature=LBD2eSeN_ekQ3xzJiEEoaw

not sure if this is fair? they said they value the cheshire at 2 ma but i thought it was around .5n? any help would be greatly appreciated <3

The Cheshire goes for .25-.5 nons it just seems to depend on the trading partners, but looking at the successful trade thread I’d say you can get .5 for it alone with the right person and I wouldn’t trade it for 2 ma
Forum/search.php?keywords=Cheshire+&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

The Cheshire usually gets 0.25n - 0.5n is an outlier trade.
they are offering on exactly 0.5n, so the trade was fair.

[nicole]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95452530&userid=881679&signature=LBD2eSeN_ekQ3xzJiEEoaw

not sure if this is fair? they said they value the cheshire at 2 ma but i thought it was around .5n? any help would be greatly appreciated <3

The Cheshire goes for .25-.5 nons it just seems to depend on the trading partners, but looking at the successful trade thread I’d say you can get .5 for it alone with the right person and I wouldn’t trade it for 2 ma
Forum/search.php?keywords=Cheshire+&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

Those trades are outliers as the rest of them clearly depict Cheshire cats trading for / swapping for other 1 MA pets. Especially considering the fact that one of the trades in which the Cheshire Cat is depicted as .25-.5n is from an auction- where you can expect overpay. Cheshire cats are only 2 MAs and I’ve asked many other traders in the Chickensmoothie discord server and they have agreed with me