The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Klauss]

I dont know if this is fair since i dont know a thing about list pets

[Neoncherry64]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96497384&userid=538817&signature=4LbIeqmVK3JKX4812HzvHw

any opinions on this?

Personally, I'd accept that trade - all of them are old uncommons, and all true dates, making them worth quite a bit, and they want a re-release in turn, rather than a true date. I'd do it!

Edit: this pet is not a list pet, and worth at least one or more ‘09
Rares (depending on who you ask) but I still wouldn’t recommend trading any VR down for uncommons, as most people want to trade down, and not up. You will have an extremely hard time trading those uncommons up for a pet worth the same as the bunny.

Also, uncommons are never rereleased, so every uncommon is “true date” so to speak. You should never judge trade fairness solely on weather a pet is rereleased or not!

[milou1125]

I dont know if this is fair since i dont know a thing about list pets

That is massively unfair. Nonononono they're just normal VRs

[Neoncherry64]

I dont know if this is fair since i dont know a thing about list pets

That is massively unfair. Nonononono they're just normal VRs

Not sure about the fairness of the c$ value as I don’t trade c$ much, but the pps cocoon is valued up to a mid advent, and is definitely not a normal VR.

[emmiedee]

I don't know what things are worth on this site anymore. Is this fair? Thanks!

And this one too? :)

[LittleBodyBigHeart]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96497384&userid=538817&signature=4LbIeqmVK3JKX4812HzvHw

any opinions on this?

Personally, I'd accept that trade - all of them are old uncommons, and all true dates, making them worth quite a bit, and they want a re-release in turn, rather than a true date. I'd do it!

Edit: this pet is not a list pet, and worth at least one or more ‘09
Rares (depending on who you ask) but I still wouldn’t recommend trading any VR down for uncommons, as most people want to trade down, and not up. You will have an extremely hard time trading those uncommons up for a pet worth the same as the bunny.

Also, uncommons are never rereleased, so every uncommon is “true date” so to speak. You should never judge trade fairness solely on weather a pet is rereleased or not!

i guess i should have mentioned that i'm collecting '09-'12 uncommon dogs. and i don't plan on trading them up at all. i was just wondering if this was fair rarity wise, like how many '10-'11 uncommons would add up to a '10 vr

[PastelDog]

Hi, I'm wondering if this trade for the 2021 banner dog is worth it? xx

[Guest]

I dont know if this is fair since i dont know a thing about list pets

That is massively unfair. Nonononono they're just normal VRs

pls dont give false advice. the cocoon is a MA which is valued at 250 - 300 c$. only the rat is a regular vr, valued at 35 - 55 c$. however, ur right about it being unfair to the c$

[milou1125]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96507880&userid=1014938&signature=IRFuK_EEl0eVuMahSIUWSw
1200 C$ for UR banana. Thoughts?

[Zeena]

New topic!: Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4642718