The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[gentaro]

Is this trade fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93375221&userid=776760&signature=AYU9eKmLOTyZt8S1GHDwDw

[skunksmell]

Thoughts? Which side would you rather have?
Also, how much is blue ice rat going for these days? Thank you so much! c:
I value the llama store pet as a mid to high advent.

[kmaybell]

Is this trade fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93375221&userid=776760&signature=AYU9eKmLOTyZt8S1GHDwDw

Hi! Both the malk mutant and the shima lt from the 09 staff litter go for more. The malk mutant goes for 1ma which is 8 rares from 2009 (technically 7-9 but 8 is most common). They are offering you only a little over half that (4 09 rares + the '10 and '12 rare) so I would consider it unfair to you.

[Xanpoon]

Which one should I take?

This trade for Dogtag
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93319885&userid=725734&signature=Uui2X7uM-tNbErCpnI0izQ
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93342124&userid=725734&signature=Gsndq3rpE-_OqOjnxZIhDQ
or
this trade for Bengal cat?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93321053&userid=725734&signature=IF8N2VaSbhsNFPUbsJukVw
Or maybe this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93351923&userid=725734&signature=cpU_vINEIheNzMEFWlsAXQ
Even this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93358575&userid=725734&signature=H3Pm8y0eyrWTtDxYqgogiQ

[debbie.]

How fair/unfair was this?

Is that malk egg going for something crazy now? I just added it to my wishlist once I realized I was missing it from my collection. I felt like an 09 rare was a decent offer for the egg but idk yall id love some help

[Cøpacetic]

Is this trade fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93375221&userid=776760&signature=AYU9eKmLOTyZt8S1GHDwDw

Hi! Both the malk mutant and the shima lt from the 09 staff litter go for more. The malk mutant goes for 1ma which is 8 rares from 2009 (technically 7-9 but 8 is most common). They are offering you only a little over half that (4 09 rares + the '10 and '12 rare) so I would consider it unfair to you.

I'm on the other side of this trade and I'm a little confused how my trade is so low. I asked the "how much is this pet worth?" thread about my sitting cats and they said they could easily snag 2 09 rares each.

[kmaybell]

Is this trade fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93375221&userid=776760&signature=AYU9eKmLOTyZt8S1GHDwDw

Hi! Both the malk mutant and the shima lt from the 09 staff litter go for more. The malk mutant goes for 1ma which is 8 rares from 2009 (technically 7-9 but 8 is most common). They are offering you only a little over half that (4 09 rares + the '10 and '12 rare) so I would consider it unfair to you.

I'm on the other side of this trade and I'm a little confused how my trade is so low. I asked the "how much is this pet worth?" thread about my sitting cats and they said they could easily snag 2 09 rares each.

I don't think I have ever heard of those cats being more than normal 09 rares. Sitting cats are well liked but unless they are list pets or warrior cats they are just normal rares. Sorry about the confusion! Maybe someone would overpay if they really wanted a specific sitting cat but that shouldn't be considered its normal value :)

[Cøpacetic]

Is this a fair trade?? Quick pls!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93376407&userid=881527&signature=sZuHXCIQgUG8gGCBbJaG6Q

[little sunshine]

-snip-
I'm on the other side of this trade and I'm a little confused how my trade is so low. I asked the "how much is this pet worth?" thread about my sitting cats and they said they could easily snag 2 09 rares each.

I don't think I have ever heard of those cats being more than normal 09 rares. Sitting cats are well liked but unless they are list pets or warrior cats they are just normal rares. Sorry about the confusion! Maybe someone would overpay if they really wanted a specific sitting cat but that shouldn't be considered its normal value :)

I agree with kmaybell
warriors tend to fetch 3-4 09 rares
where as those normal sitting cat rarely fetch more than just an 09 rare

[Laetificat]

Is this fair to me? I think my item is old
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93335516&userid=596560&signature=MdKBu8lvlpeFPOMA3yMdhg