The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Ari!]

Could I get some help with these two trades? Thank you in advance
Trade 1
Trade 2
Edit: could I get some help with this item trade?

trade 1
Blue Ice Rat 2.5-3 MA's
purple bat dog 2-3Ma's
plus the other rares, I think its a fair trade for both sides
trade 2
pink patchy September worth 14-16 '09 rares or 2MAs
purple bat dog 2-3Ma's therefore a bit unfair to you as you can probably get more.

[blurry_cat1]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201405&userid=994729&signature=pcXn_go3I0PCU2MDsjZJNQ
fast

[Ari!]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201405&userid=994729&signature=pcXn_go3I0PCU2MDsjZJNQ
fast

i know the other Carousel Horses are worth 2MA's so I'm assuming the same for the zebra one.
i cant find a value for the spelltag kitsune either but I know the black one goes for 2MA's.
earth day deer is worth around 2 '09 rares, I couldn't find anything about the mother nature one.
because these are the values of not the specific store pets in this trade I would take this with a grain of salt and wait for another opinion, plus some of the values might be a little bit off

[_Eleanor_]

Could I please get help for his one?
I would be offering more Uncommons and older pets, but they'd offer a larger amount of pets. Is the trade fair? Or should I ask for less or more? Thank you in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201318&userid=1017271&signature=kcnnS_HUrbtXJ_DcCUMEbg

[Ari!]

Could I please get help for his one?
I would be offering more Uncommons and older pets, but they'd offer a larger amount of pets. Is the trade fair? Or should I ask for less or more? Thank you in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201318&userid=1017271&signature=kcnnS_HUrbtXJ_DcCUMEbg

Very unfair to you. something to keep in mind when trading is the 2:1 rule which a lot of people (but not all) go by. the idea is that 2 pets with the same rarity (and sometimes species), from the same year, are worth 1 pet of the same rarity from the year below. eg 2 2013 uncommons are worth 2 2012 uncommons. this goes for the same with rairties wjthin years. eg two commons from the same year is worth 1 uncommon from the other year; 2 very commons is worth 1 common etc.
you don't have to follow this rule, but it can be helpful with determining "fairness".
(:

[Booplesnoott]

May I ask for some help with this trade please ? I'm not sure at all if it's fair or not >.<

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94193759&userid=1009426&signature=sY9OrWrTF9qnw_c59zbsvQ

Thanks in advance !

Anyone ? ;u;

[ketchdown]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201262&userid=974084&signature=lpJOWvYPO2I4YNV7zhYmfg

need a bit of help figuring out the worth of the other side ^^

[Ilovesmoothies!]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94164243&userid=75661&signature=Gtyfr6Of_40DevdQszOSeA

How is this? Thanks!

And this please
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94163834&userid=75661&signature=hnjE5qNAamm38d7uFBsgeQ

Any help would be very much appreciated!

[Ari!]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201262&userid=974084&signature=lpJOWvYPO2I4YNV7zhYmfg

need a bit of help figuring out the worth of the other side ^^

Swirl Valentines PPS mid october, same as Pointy Pink Pastel, together roughly worth 7 '09 rares
a late 2018 store pet is equal to an early 2010 rare.
plus '09 pet
to round it up, id say their side is worth 8.5 '09 rares

[AlexBlu]

Just checking on this ^^" a bit sleep deprived and want someone a little more clearer headed to make sure both sides are fair <3 thank you in advance!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201304&userid=291429&signature=2tXCMQzP5umMCt11RyA0UQ

not gonna add it all up but looks a bit unfair to you using the 2:1 rule

I edited it to what they had available to make it what I believe would be fair ^^" anyone able to help out on the edited version below?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201517&userid=291429&signature=y1mjmNcB8vTkaPk4eJFPBA