hghghghg634 wrote:Are these fair?
1: trades/viewtrade.php?id=94187827&userid=432368&signature=BRDQHk8KCotN6_WstWgx-Q
2: trades/viewtrade.php?id=94177656&userid=432368&signature=OiLBz_Au5jVrxi7Ba6D3cw
3: trades/viewtrade.php?id=94188407&userid=432368&signature=u_bgjcmyRh1g3vg1LULJbw
4: trades/viewtrade.php?id=94188835&userid=432368&signature=UwGsVxZJdX4s3SIW8MT0JA
- trade 1 - there is very little updated info about the 08 reindeer plushie, the cs items guide puts it at an 09 rare/very rare from October or November. I think people are still generally trading 1-2 09 rares for it, so this trade is pretty fair.
personally I'd stick to valuing the reindeer plushie at an 09 vr / 2 09 rares, so I'd accept this (if you're not a fan of rats, swap it out for another late 09 rare).
----------------------------------
trade 2 - this is gonna be a bit confusing due to the cross years so bear with.
their side:
- early 2012 uncommon
- 5x 2013 uncommons
- 2019 uncommon
- 2020 uncommon
your side:
- late 2012 uncommon
- 2013 common, 2x 2013 uncommons
- 2x 2014 uncommon
- 2019 uncommon, 2x 2019 commons
- 2020 uncommon
if you follow the 3-month rule (i.e., pets can trade for -/+ 3 months of their release date, as long as it's within the same rarity) and if you follow the 2:1 rule, then:
- their 2020 uncommon is a month out to be able to swap for your 2020 uncommon (unfair to you)
- their 2019 uncommon is a month out of being able to swap for your 2019 uncommon (unfair to them)
^^^ I'd say that this cancels out due to both of you being a month under/over, so fair ultimately
- 2013 uncommon = 2 2014 uncommons, + the 2 2013 uncommons & common = 3.5 2013 uncommons, so the leftover 1.5 2013 uncommons could cover the 2019 commons with value leftover on their side.
sorry if that was confusing oof- ultimately I'd say they're overpaying slightly due to the leftover 2013 uncommons and the date difference between their 2012 uncomon and yours. I hope this makes sense! it all comes down to personal preference at the end of the day.
----------------------------------
trade 3 - your tess dragon is just a regular rare worth 3-month rule or 2 09 rares. they're offering an 09 warrior cat (leopardstar) which go for 2-3 09 rares each, as well as another '09 & '11 rare, totalling their side to 3.25-4.25 09 rares. unfair to them, they're overpaying.
- check out the warrior cat guide here, as the 08 warriors are worth more, so just fyi <:
----------------------------------
trade 4 - guinea pigs have decent demand I believe, but nevertheless this particular guinea is worth 3-month rule or 2 2010 rares (or 1 09 rare, being a 2010 VR). the sitting cat they're offering is an 09 warrior (longtail), which again, goes for 2-3 09 rares. I'd say they're overpaying, unfair to them.
- if they had 1 09 rare + the other two rares, I'd say that's a pretty good deal, with the 2014 rare and/or 2017 rare covering the heightened demand guinea pigs have, so maybe edit it to that <:
Saltyweeb0 wrote:should i accept???
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94195700&userid=1017440&signature=iyqjvyY010MtI4zaByfOrQ
- following this chart, your 2011 rare = 4 2011 uncommons, so technically they're overpaying. however, they're offering low-demand pets in exchange for your dog, so it's up to you whether you accept or not - if you like the pets they're offering, then go for it.
personally, I would not accept as I find ponies/rats trade a lot worse than dogs, so maybe exchange the 4 2011s they're offering for 4 2011 dogs/cats/other higher demand pets <:
