The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[blurry_cat1]

Hi! I autoed one of bids and wanted to know more about trade value ^^
//auto was 1ma
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94159576&userid=994729&signature=qTtiZVBj1bHHOzG8_o_kFw

[Swerenity]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94160211&userid=900112&signature=aGJb_PEfxxfuz40sF4DP2A

is this fair demand and value wise?

[Assumed Gender]

Hi! I autoed one of bids and wanted to know more about trade value ^^
//auto was 1ma
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94159576&userid=994729&signature=qTtiZVBj1bHHOzG8_o_kFw

they traded all of that for just the pet you had???? im confused

[stellarzorua]

hi! could someone please help me with this trade? thank you!

[Dead or Alive]

Does this look fair? Thanks in advance!!🤠

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94159257&userid=911581&signature=IO5BwH47OuTyTDDPN_-Cjg

[ezrababii]

Was this fair? I don't know much about store pets --> c$ values anymore (pm me if you can as i might not find it on this thread :'))

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94156114&userid=957635&signature=VSojBDOjwL62u2jyf2TKMQ
--
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94156123&userid=957635&signature=U_6PhbS9_V0yChtlJrAn4w

[Assumed Gender]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94165613&userid=1003578&signature=VEAmLpj5MRh_UMSDDL7KQQ


Is this fair demand and worth wise

[draculauraaa]

please help!! :3 trades/viewtrade.php?id=94164276&userid=899291&signature=rTguo45d5fPdKrJaO04eqg

please help meee!!!!!!

[ahirked]

please help!! :3 trades/viewtrade.php?id=94164276&userid=899291&signature=rTguo45d5fPdKrJaO04eqg

please help meee!!!!!!

I answered this on the previous page!

Does this look fair? Thanks in advance!!🤠

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94159257&userid=911581&signature=IO5BwH47OuTyTDDPN_-Cjg

warriors go for 2-3 09 rares each, and the target dog goes for 1.5-2 MAs.

their side adds up to 5 09 rares* + 40c$ (1-2 09 rares) = 6-7 09 rares, which on its own would be fair for your two warrior cats. they have not added enough to cover the worth of the target dog.
* not counting the added items and pets from 2013/2014

Was this fair? I don't know much about store pets --> c$ values anymore (pm me if you can as i might not find it on this thread :'))

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94156114&userid=957635&signature=VSojBDOjwL62u2jyf2TKMQ
--
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94156123&userid=957635&signature=U_6PhbS9_V0yChtlJrAn4w

trade 1 - 2014 stores are generally worth 55-60c$, but given the dragoncat stores' popularity, this seems pretty fair. I unfortunately couldn't find any c$ trades with this pet in particular, but judging from other 2014 stores', this seems like the lower end of their value (see below).

trade 2 - same as above, however, there is definitely a tendency to pay a lot more for these due to demand. estimating their demand value at 150-200c$ and going by the lower value, you hit the nail on the head, so this is pretty fair imo <:

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94165613&userid=1003578&signature=VEAmLpj5MRh_UMSDDL7KQQ


Is this fair demand and worth wise

rose pps = 0.25 nons, or 3-4 MA

their side:
- green toxic bun = 6-7 09 rares + 1 09 uncommon (source), so just about 1 MA
- purple/pink advent tess horse = 6-8 09 rares, since it turned very rare at the same time as several other tess horses/pets of the same value (see here)
- tinsel dog / christmas tree dog = 6-8 09 rares (source + trades consistently fetch 1 MA)
- pocky = low-mid advent, but consistently fetches 1 MA
- 2008 red/white scarf & red/green scarf = low advent (0.75 MA) (source)
- 2008 dog santa hat = low-mid advent (source)
- cupid wolf = early-mid 09 rare/very rare +

that totals about 6.25 MAs, which is pretty big overpay for the red rose pps.
I think 4 MAs would be fine in exchange for the red rose pps - to make this fair, remove the 2008 scarves (x2) and the 2008 dog santa hat, and then that will be 4 MAs exactly <:

[The Lady Amalthea]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94130698&userid=938809&signature=3I-MrVkm_t6NAVRTk-DraA

Is this fair? And if not how can it be made fair