The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Lovebean]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94160228&userid=675207&signature=KiseuL6m7MlhcAVWUnLDEw

Any help on this please. I want to make sure we are betting getting a good offer.

[PixieSwirl]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94102194&userid=940053&signature=D0g50Xm0vlr1Z0cAmhi_uw


trades/viewtrade.php?id=94101547&userid=940053&signature=ddjKajZges-0RGdPtNW7Ug
^is there any thing i can add/remove to make this fair? i really like the flower :'D

[Lucky222]

I need help with this trade for two 2010 easter eggs

[blurry_cat1]

Hi! I autoed one of bids and wanted to know more about trade value ^^
//auto was 1ma
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94159576&userid=994729&signature=qTtiZVBj1bHHOzG8_o_kFw

[EditPink]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94137210&userid=902320&signature=HQGvSd5Wj1Cbwh-f4yUXZA

thanks

[PixieSwirl]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94102194&userid=940053&signature=D0g50Xm0vlr1Z0cAmhi_uw


trades/viewtrade.php?id=94101547&userid=940053&signature=ddjKajZges-0RGdPtNW7Ug
^is there any thing i can add/remove to make this fair? i really like the flower :'D

[ahirked]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94160228&userid=675207&signature=KiseuL6m7MlhcAVWUnLDEw

Any help on this please. I want to make sure we are betting getting a good offer.

v unfair to them, unless i'm missing something on the draft horse,

their christmas socks and scarfs, santa hat, hearts items alone are worth an 09' rare - very rare each, i'm unaware of the ' merry christmas ' sign, as i'm going by this guide, but i'd personally value it as an 09' rare - very rare,,

i'd further go to say that the first birthday items, cookie, candy cane, holly pajamas, and the hannakuah items can be valued along side an 09' common/uncommon/rare/very rare each, just going by successful trades with items within the same release sets,,

birthday items example , valuing them at 1-2 09' rares,
cake items, example two- valuing them at an 09' common/uncommon each,


i tried using searches to get an idea on the other 09' items, but couldn't find any, < 3
just an idea / base, it'd be unfair to the item side,

whilst I agree this is extremely unfair to the top, the value you provided for the oldest items is outdated - the guide can be a bit inaccurate in that respect, so I'd recommend using the 'how much is this item worth' and share your item trades in conjunction with it.

that said, the red/white christmas socks go for 1 MA each, and the red/white christmas scarf goes for a low advent (0.75 MA) - source; trade. I personally have been valuing the red/green socks and scarf at the same values.

the santa hat is also worth a low-mid advent (source). the merry christmas sign I'm unfortunately not too sure about, particularly as trades for it have varied from a couple of 2009 uncommons to a t6 advent (source). following the trend of the other items released at this time, but bearing in mind that signs are less popular, I'd guesstimate that this item is now worth around a low advent or so; I'd be less inclined to follow the outdated values placing it at a 2009 uncommon/rare.

other items:
- hearts = 1 09 rare/very rare
- cake slices = 09 common/uncommon ea.
- st pat's socks = 2009 uncommon
- shamrock leaf = 2010 uncommon (since it was rereleased in 2010)
- candycane = 2009 uncommon
- holly pj pants = I'd argue 2 2009 uncommons/1 2009 rare per item from this set, based on scarcity alone
- cookie = 2009 common/uncommon
- dreidle necklace, coins = 2010 uncommon ea.
- red envelope, cake, royal wizard jacket, ring-toss token, silver stocking, 200k glasses, clockwork mouse = 2011 uncommon ea. (you can find all these items in the 'how much is this item worth?' thread)

all the other items are worth a common/uncommon from release date - the rest of their items range from 2012-2015. if you want specifics feel free to ask <:

ultimately, the most important thing I'd stress is that the 2008 christmas items are worth a lot more than the cs items guide places them at. the trade you sent was very unfair! hope this helps ;v;

[kqt_scratch]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94155119&userid=908566&signature=nbnA6IX77A2Ch9hzreapsw
I'm not familiar with item worths, so I'm completely in the dark about this, any help would be appreciated! I can edit the trade, too. I'm just not sure what I should add if I need to.

[ahirked]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94155119&userid=908566&signature=nbnA6IX77A2Ch9hzreapsw
I'm not familiar with item worths, so I'm completely in the dark about this, any help would be appreciated! I can edit the trade, too. I'm just not sure what I should add if I need to.

unfair to you!
- sugarplum bat = 2011 uncommon
- stompy = 2013 uncommon+, as 2013 slumber party items are fairly popular
- mina bat plushie = 2019 uncommon

they're only offering the gryphon bat plushie (2018 uncommon) and nessie (2019 uncommon). this doesn't add up to your side!
the nessie plush would be a fair swap for your mina bat plush, but they need to add another 2011 uncommon and 2013 uncommon+ for this to be fair <:

[A Vengeful God]

Hello my lovely lovelies. Any ideas if these are fair? Or what might need to be added?

xXXx

XxxX

xXx