The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[sapphirelion]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94122667&userid=172675&signature=S_VEMFVj98JR7P19p93PHA

Is this fair?

Here's what I've found:

Your Joker is worth 1-1.5 nons

Their side worths:
joker bun = 1-1.5 nons
grown white scarf dog = 3-4 '09 rares
2008 vr dog
2009 r dog
2014 r deer

So according to that thread it looks like they are overpaying

Successful trades including a Joker Dog:
trade 1
Joker = Blue Toxic + Green Toxic + Red-X + 4 Store Pets + 2008 VR + 22 2009 R + 600 C$ +more
trade 2
Pink Sorbet + Green Sorbet = Joker
trade 2
UR avocado + VR 08' Light-faced PPS + 09' White-footed African Wild Dog + Yellow Punk Store Pet = Joker Dog
trade 3
RBM + UR Grapes + Blue Snowflake Scarf Dog + Warrior Cat + 402 C$ = Joker Dog
trade 4
TD Joker (valued @ 2 nons) for Pink balloon (0.5 nons), Blue balloon (0.25-0.5 nons, valued @ 0.5) and Nontag (1 non)

More can be found here:
Successful VR/OMG So Rare Trades Thread

[sapphirelion]

zebra for red android?

and

zonkey for ur holly + red android + pink punk

Trade 1:
their zebra is the Mountain Zebra and is worth about 1-1.5 nons

Your Red Android is worth 0.5-1 non

So in the Zebra alone they seem to be paying fair/overpaying, but especially with the other pets they added they appear to be overpaying.


Trade 2:
Their zonkey is worth 1.5-2 nons

Your Red Android is worth 0.5-1 non
Your Pink Punk is worth 0.5 non
Your UR Holly dog is worth 1 non
This makes your side worth about 2-2.5 nons

So you would either be paying fairly or overpaying for the zonkey, it depends on what you worth your pets at

[Coraline]

zebra for red android?

and

zonkey for ur holly + red android + pink punk

Zonkey trade is fair since it more so gets 2n and their side is android 0.5 + punk 0.5 + holly 1n

Zebra should be valued at around 1 non usually but after its rarity drop its demand went down even further so some people value it a little lower, some still value at 1n, either way the zebra is technically over by 0.5 nons since the android is only 0.5 but its demand is horrible so its your choice

[Lovebean]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94110299&userid=675207&signature=MjyiXS42eUQjpxZSd68Cnw

Is this fair? Ty!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94117688&userid=675207&signature=1oWatk8MoaxqUXAo3d7Haw

And this one please.

[stellarzorua]

hi! not sure if these two trades are fair since they're off list but any help would be v much appreciated!!
i believe trade 1 would be underpay considering the ex-advent list, but I wanted to make sure the values on trade 2 in '09 rares match up ^^'

trade one and trade two

could I get some help with these ones? thank you!

[ouspiae]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94124848&userid=731952&signature=2sT_fcN8jdLcJe00OAcFcA
Can someone help me please?

[KJen]

Would this be fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94102606&userid=322531&signature=mu-ndtcTWoTuPB6fitKcew

[Ruruskadoo]

Is this fair? Thanks!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94122476&userid=119355&signature=WpuoFXapzg_Vor8cea1-Cg

[EditPink]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94122558&userid=902320&signature=wtkJHZQigQ-9pt5jAzDN5Q

[Ruruskadoo]

Is this fair? Thanks!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94122476&userid=119355&signature=WpuoFXapzg_Vor8cea1-Cg