The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Flicka]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91916954&userid=9355&signature=TrASzwPypADZJWbXTS9org
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94027784&userid=9355&signature=06tIFlmqgOMuScHjSIGLzg are these fair all around?

[~Phantom]

bump!

Hi everyone! Newbie here. Is/was this fair? It’s for the same one pet.

1) trades/viewtrade.php?id=94102169&userid=1016833&signature=5PTliE1P7KXviC2eIr8Mqg
(Auto-cancelled)

2) trades/viewtrade.php?id=94113338&userid=1016833&signature=bgCDgSRuhygasXadXNSGHg

3) I’m also considering to ask for their [UC 2015 Christmas fox, UC 2020 bird, and UC 2020 bunny] for my [R 2016 Halloween rat and the UC 2018 pps horse shown above]. All are on our wishlists. They want overpay so I’m not sure if I’m offering enough. If not, then would this be a fair trade in non-overpay situations? Or am I asking for too much?

Thank you in advance!!

So both of those trades are unfair for you. The third, is also unfair for you. Unless we know which christmas fox, there doesn't seem to be any need for overpay since it's a 2015 UC (likely with average demand or none really). The 2016 R rat would be enough for those three pets with a bit of overpay on your side. Still would be a tad unfair for you.

[Neoncherry64]

hi, could i get this trade looked at please ? i'm not sure of the worths of the pets offered or exactly how much my store pet is going for. thank you in advance ! (feel free to pm an answer - i'll make sure to edit to say i've gotten it answered if that's the case)

2013 stores go for a “low advent” pet, or around 3-6 ‘09 rares. Currently their side is worth about 4.5 09 rares. However, the rat and the horses aren’t the best with demand. When dealing with low demand ‘09 rares like rats and ponies I’d try to aim for the higher end, especially with stores.

[glitter]

zebra for red android?

and

zonkey for ur holly + red android + pink punk

Been asking for a long time pls help

[MaddyHasIssues]

Hi there is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94101271&userid=859460&signature=1pjE4OF3RAXZM2cjp18vbg

[Neoncherry64]

Hi there is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94101271&userid=859460&signature=1pjE4OF3RAXZM2cjp18vbg

Technically speaking, this is overpay as that dog is only “worth” a regular 2021 rare and the giraffe is worth a 2010 rare.

HOWEVER- that dog still has a ton of inflated demand and auctions for it still go for multiple ‘10/‘09 rares and sometimes even very rares. It’s up to you what you want to trade yours for though.

[EmberzTale]

Could anyone help with this trade? I'm not the best with item values.

Thanks for any help!

[Silver Tiger~]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94120170&userid=481829&signature=S9WC7WZdSmIWaX68VFaeVg trying to figure out how to make this fair, what should I remove from my side? (they sent me the trade, and I'm too braindead to figure this out)

[trilobitemeat]

Would this be fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94120291&userid=772523&signature=SSeInPU6ayadE4mT0h0gxQ

[Ruruskadoo]

Fair? My foal is older but I don't know if demand makes it fair because they're offering a dragon.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94120234&userid=119355&signature=zDThR7QEijIOGpuC9zj5Gg



EDIT: oh geez if someone could help with this I'd really appreciate it too; I know most of those are commons and I assume it's probably more than fair to me but since it's so many pets and I'm pretty bad at gauging fairness I'd be grateful if someone could confirm it, thanks!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94120325&userid=119355&signature=_NoVLTCcerer-9q800DRTA