The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[nvsebleed]

Would this be fair? Idk if malks have higher value.
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94113390

Wrong link, use the one at the bottom of the page so we can see!

[iago.]

can someone please tell me if this is fair? or what should be added on either side to make it so?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94117520&userid=964094&signature=w1EVozjxWKHowyN6U2S-WQ

[Neoncherry64]

Would this be fair? Idk if malks have higher value.
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94113390&userid=772523&signature=n3EkH4s9QwlFWvXY3OvdMA

Sorry yes I forgot about that, thank you

Rarity and date wise, this is perfectly fair. Both malk pets and lions have very good demand, but neither pet is worth any more than the other :)

Could anyone help with this trade? I'm not the best with item values.

Thanks for any help!

All these items are on the newer side, with the oldest being 2018 I believe. New items are mostly valued at commons or very commons, but some of the items are fairly popular like the horns and crystals so I’d say the amount of overpay they’re offering seems fair. Maybe get a second opinion though.

[reflections.]

i am a lost cause when it comes to trades help

[cat party]

i am a lost cause when it comes to trades help

Red malk dragon is .25 a non (3-4 mas) and their side is only 2 mas, so unfair to you

[cat party]

can someone please tell me if this is fair? or what should be added on either side to make it so?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94117520&userid=964094&signature=w1EVozjxWKHowyN6U2S-WQ

Your pet is worth an MA, so about 7 09 rares. They're offering you a gold robot dog (high october list, 4 09 rares) and a rare warrior, which is worth 2-3 09 rares. So their side totals to 6 or 7 09 rares, so it's up to you :)

[ԏєѧѻӆғוѓԑ]

hi, could i get this trade looked at please ? i'm not sure of the worths of the pets offered or exactly how much my store pet is going for. thank you in advance ! (feel free to pm an answer - i'll make sure to edit to say i've gotten it answered if that's the case)

answered ! thank you so much !

[glitter]

zebra for red android?

and

zonkey for ur holly + red android + pink punk

[Lovebean]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94110299&userid=675207&signature=MjyiXS42eUQjpxZSd68Cnw

Is this fair? Ty!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94117688&userid=675207&signature=1oWatk8MoaxqUXAo3d7Haw

And this one please.

[zatty]

bump!

Hi everyone! Newbie here. Is/was this fair? It’s for the same one pet.

1) trades/viewtrade.php?id=94102169&userid=1016833&signature=5PTliE1P7KXviC2eIr8Mqg
(Auto-cancelled)

2) trades/viewtrade.php?id=94113338&userid=1016833&signature=bgCDgSRuhygasXadXNSGHg

3) I’m also considering to ask for their [UC 2015 Christmas fox, UC 2020 bird, and UC 2020 bunny] for my [R 2016 Halloween rat and the UC 2018 pps horse shown above]. All are on our wishlists. They want overpay so I’m not sure if I’m offering enough. If not, then would this be a fair trade in non-overpay situations? Or am I asking for too much?

Thank you in advance!!