The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[miilk]

Is this a fair trade? I just got sent it, and I'm not sure. It feels like they're over paying.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94049341&userid=749246&signature=K0qP7wCTBxYXAeKjE1tUbA

[Chemicalized]

Im not too sure what to do with this trade, I dont do a lot of list trading so im not sure what the value of the ur kirin is at the moment and im not sure how people value the nick sunback or any of the other older pets

thanks in advance!

[calidogz]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94049760&userid=1014165&signature=0uuJ4vmaCkiS1CgLp4b_Eg

I dont really trade im just here to watch things grow

[Redbird]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94049760&userid=1014165&signature=0uuJ4vmaCkiS1CgLp4b_Eg

I dont really trade im just here to watch things grow

extremely unfair to you; you could get at least one older rare for those items. Trying to recall if the horse is from 2010 christmas or 2011, but you'd be looking at a rare from that year for it.

[☼find your wings☼]

I really love the BA but I'm unsure!

[miilk]

Is this a fair trade? I just got sent it, and I'm not sure. It feels like they're over paying.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94049341&userid=749246&signature=K0qP7wCTBxYXAeKjE1tUbA

[calidogz]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94049760&userid=1014165&signature=0uuJ4vmaCkiS1CgLp4b_Eg

I dont really trade im just here to watch things grow

extremely unfair to you; you could get at least one older rare for those items. Trying to recall if the horse is from 2010 christmas or 2011, but you'd be looking at a rare from that year for it.

Okay tysm <3

[ahirked]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94049760&userid=1014165&signature=0uuJ4vmaCkiS1CgLp4b_Eg

I dont really trade im just here to watch things grow

extremely unfair to you; you could get at least one older rare for those items. Trying to recall if the horse is from 2010 christmas or 2011, but you'd be looking at a rare from that year for it.

Okay tysm <3

I disagree actually, that horse plushie is worth a 2011 uncommon, maybe 2 2011 uncommons at a stretch.

[Redbird]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94049760&userid=1014165&signature=0uuJ4vmaCkiS1CgLp4b_Eg

I dont really trade im just here to watch things grow

extremely unfair to you; you could get at least one older rare for those items. Trying to recall if the horse is from 2010 christmas or 2011, but you'd be looking at a rare from that year for it.

I disagree actually, that horse plushie is worth a 2011 uncommon, maybe 2 2011 uncommons at a stretch.

I've been offered rares recently for my extras, which is why I said what I did.
Totally possible that's not the norm, but it's what I've experienced most commonly in the last few months.

[fen!]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94045550&userid=927542&signature=oifLxTtg7xRG6m5ia21eNw
thanks in advance