The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[WoodlandPunk]

+++

++++

Are either of these fair? Some opinions would be helpful

[Thovatos]

Can I have thoughts on this trade? I was the one with the grinners. Was this the right call? I've found it pretty hard to trade grinners off and same with the joker buns for their value worths. (I ended up having 5 joker buns at one point... and Grinners? I had plenty of them too~)

We both valued my side at 3 nons for the sunjewel 3-3.5 nons.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93764261&userid=340145&signature=rSoNKmc5kZ41eS6WmvQNOA

[GhostPants]

I dont really pay attention to item worths, so how is this trade?

An offer for my kirin how is it?

[BIG TRADE WARNING] and this for all my warriors + like 3 store pets
ghostpants

[everlore]

help! is this fair for my UR flower?
i think their side is 0.75 nons but i'm not sure.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93775193&userid=913310&signature=f2T8nyA5poTKaY2UB6YtWA

[badass skeleton]

So I've got some bids for my zodiac dog, can someone tell me what is fair / the best with demand in mind
xx
xx
xx
xx
xx

Also this please trades/viewtrade.php?id=93762726&userid=813303&signature=RXtyqTuTUvSegtVEpLNXog

[{Marie.}]

Would this be fair for a 2014 store pet? some of the items their asking for also have some value that i know of but idk if this is underpay or overpay on either side

[Frozen_Cherry]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93331009&userid=725461&signature=zwj2ADPGunYYglnKuPm6Aw
(bulk item trade ^)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93713613&userid=725461&signature=iFOsgMFMBSPYvlHYUX-TlA
(true date swap)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93730805&userid=725461&signature=2AafkbOi3uVed_UkeD3hYw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93762295&userid=725461&signature=BspW5dV_dm5-vJbs04x0iQ[/quote]

any help is highly appreciated! <3

[Ari!]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93331009&userid=725461&signature=zwj2ADPGunYYglnKuPm6Aw
(bulk item trade ^)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93713613&userid=725461&signature=iFOsgMFMBSPYvlHYUX-TlA
(true date swap)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93730805&userid=725461&signature=2AafkbOi3uVed_UkeD3hYw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93762295&userid=725461&signature=BspW5dV_dm5-vJbs04x0iQ

any help is highly appreciated! <3[/quote]
with the third trade, by going with the 2:1 year rule as well as the 2:1 rare to VR rule, I would say that they're over paying, although if you value those pets more than the pets they're offering then deny. everyone values their pets differently.
what i mean by the 2:1 rare to VR rule, is two rares from one year would equal a VR from the same year. not everyone goes by this rule though, but if you were to their pets that they're offering would equal 2 2010 VR. although, the older the rares, I feel the less this rule applies. personally i would accept this trade but thats because I don't like ponies that much, and as well with the fact that they're offering a malk pet. but if you feel otherwise i think it would be perfectly reasonable to deny this trade

[Amethyst The Gem]

I haven't traded much since the new system has started falling into place, what do y'all think about this trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93774804&userid=423192&signature=DRKUBNy_08ICJSeRinaoHQ


*edit: I forgot the trade also involves 260 C$

[Frozen_Cherry]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93331009&userid=725461&signature=zwj2ADPGunYYglnKuPm6Aw
(bulk item trade ^)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93713613&userid=725461&signature=iFOsgMFMBSPYvlHYUX-TlA
(true date swap)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93762295&userid=725461&signature=BspW5dV_dm5-vJbs04x0iQ[/quote]

any help is highly appreciated! <3