The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Sunlordess]

Hey there!
I've got an auction for the store giraffes and this is currently the leading bid:
LEADING BID!
Just wanna know how fair it is!
(I'm loving the Banana dog and the BW♡♡♡)

[Friendlyflyer]

Hey there!
I've got an auction for the store giraffes and this is currently the leading bid:
LEADING BID!
Just wanna know how fair it is!
(I'm loving the Banana dog and the BW♡♡♡)

This is overpay since each of your pets is worth an early 2011 rare. The butterfly wolf alone is overpay (June 2009 VR). Using the 2:1 conversion, your side is worth about 1 2009 rare and 1 2011 rare

[dillydallydarlene]

Hey there!
I've got an auction for the store giraffes and this is currently the leading bid:
LEADING BID!
Just wanna know how fair it is!
(I'm loving the Banana dog and the BW♡♡♡)

Are they aware their BW is a Mainlist? You may wanna inquire cause this appears to me to be HUGE over pay on their side and not too fair to them

Definitely check to see if they are aware of that pet's value

Feel free to seek a second opinion

[LoveIsLove]

Was this fair/overpay on their side? I was trying to look up the rarity change on the guide to see if the dates kind of match up but I wasn’t sure what either vr dogs name was so I gave up and just edited on an item I needed. I believe this was a bit of overpay on their part since both dogs are from 2009 (though theirs is august and mine was valentines so it did fall a hair outside the three month rule alone). Though I’d appreciate a second opinion!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93768738&userid=310216&signature=szY1OooM-SCNenZzXXSWsQ

TLDR does anyone know the names of these two VR dogs?

Also how does this item trade look?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93769973&userid=310216&signature=ebH3sOSD9SQ5B4CI4hP4bA

[Mikuru Senpai]

Hello yes, is this fair?
I'm quite unsure tbh
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93771420&userid=372784&signature=1ujUG9kxtfvMVUz4b-un8w

[caffeinate]

Was this fair?

[Friendlyflyer]

Hello yes, is this fair?
I'm quite unsure tbh
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93771420&userid=372784&signature=1ujUG9kxtfvMVUz4b-un8w

Slight Overpay on their side

[rab1es]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93768752&userid=415771&signature=j2OHwB4RTMvfajUQUZXVKQ

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91155941&userid=415771&signature=qim92U3fQ8Lj-S5eycnDkw

thoughts on any of these? i know nothing about rarities. thanks in advance!

[ithiria]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93768752&userid=415771&signature=j2OHwB4RTMvfajUQUZXVKQ

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91155941&userid=415771&signature=qim92U3fQ8Lj-S5eycnDkw

thoughts on any of these? i know nothing about rarities. thanks in advance!

the first one is unfair to you
Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4461620&start=10#p132664832
the light leo is worth 1.25 to 1.5 MA's only ...they ask for 3 MA's

the second is about fair, but i personally wouldnt accept demand wise - most pets they offerd have a very bad demand (rats/bwolves) and are hard to trade off fairly - your pets, especially the sleipnir and the hollyfox have a great demand and can easily go for overpay.

edit: i just checked the thread again, the second trade is unfair too, the hollyfox can go for up to 3 MA's and the Sleipnir goes for 2 MA's - their side isnt worth that much

[LoveIsLove]

Was this fair/overpay on their side? I was trying to look up the rarity change on the guide to see if the dates kind of match up but I wasn’t sure what either vr dogs name was so I gave up and just edited on an item I needed. I believe this was a bit of overpay on their part since both dogs are from 2009 (though theirs is august and mine was valentines so it did fall a hair outside the three month rule alone). Though I’d appreciate a second opinion!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93768738&userid=310216&signature=szY1OooM-SCNenZzXXSWsQ

TLDR does anyone know the names of these two VR dogs?

Also how does this item trade look?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93769973&userid=310216&signature=ebH3sOSD9SQ5B4CI4hP4bA