The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Recedinghairline]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93723984&userid=1014821&signature=pQzj9OjnhPB2NBst0ygnGA
Is this fair I haven't played in 3 years.

[Gems101]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93723984&userid=1014821&signature=pQzj9OjnhPB2NBst0ygnGA
Is this fair I haven't played in 3 years.

This is unfair to you. Your pet is a 2018 store pet

[witch-steed]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93724424&userid=85491&signature=e0i0_LkELnh2oaNGXNuuSA
Unsure about this one and might need some advice... Thank you in advance <3

[$wag23]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93717258&userid=837278&signature=brtOzfbxV6ZSf7ucTsyNqQ

Ive gotten an opinion on this trade already but can i get a 2nd opinion before i accept please

[riotgrrl]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93723770&userid=824854&signature=KqIol2Wo9gR-oteXupqS2w

is this fair ? ahh should i accept ??

[~ V ~]

- snip-

Thank you! They edited it to this. Wondering if it’s more fair now?

Also, I did get one response on this bid in my auction, but would like another detailed response just in case!

Top one is sill not fair for you, the 2019 rares don't really do much and your pet is a 2009 rare whilst their malk wold is a 2010 september rare.

Thank you so much! Any opinions on the second trade? c:

[$wag23]

- snip-

Thank you! They edited it to this. Wondering if it’s more fair now?

Also, I did get one response on this bid in my auction, but would like another detailed response just in case!

Top one is sill not fair for you, the 2019 rares don't really do much and your pet is a 2009 rare whilst their malk wold is a 2010 september rare.

Thank you so much! Any opinions on the second trade? c:

From what i see i think its fair, but i wouldn’t accept because you can 100% get a better offer

[Metax]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93724424&userid=85491&signature=e0i0_LkELnh2oaNGXNuuSA
Unsure about this one and might need some advice... Thank you in advance <3

unfair to them. the dog is from july 2009. your side is worth a 10 rare and a bit.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93723770&userid=824854&signature=KqIol2Wo9gR-oteXupqS2w

is this fair ? ahh should i accept ??

unfair to them. the fox store pet would be enough as they're from the same year.

- snip-

Thank you! They edited it to this. Wondering if it’s more fair now?

Also, I did get one response on this bid in my auction, but would like another detailed response just in case!

Top one is sill not fair for you, the 2019 rares don't really do much and your pet is a 2009 rare whilst their malk wold is a 2010 september rare.

Thank you so much! Any opinions on the second trade? c:

highly unfair to them. a 13 store pet is worth 2 09 rares and a 10 rare.

[EditPink]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93709324&userid=902320&signature=mKHxxJXqlMFaL8z16gSsDg

[Corey Taylor]

Is this fair? Does there need to be more c$?