The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[GhostPants]

Im unsure about this trade! I guess i will be taking demand into account for this
ghostpants

[FrostbitenRoses]

Need help
I ran an auction for the golden gacha dog and need help picking a winner
Which one is the best bid?
Bids
1
2 second fave
3
4 so far my fave
5
6 not big fan of the doubles
7

[Christy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93710736&userid=992&signature=bzUDpnEKyrBtmvfDR1tDlg

Fair ?

[Picklechan]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93715197&userid=133109&signature=yeEBH0ZXFT4rbmkZSFE_1w

need help with this one since i'm really clueless with items and haven't figured out the price of this one yet. thank you!

[Howl's Moving Castle]

Need help
I ran an auction for the golden gacha dog and need help picking a winner
Which one is the best bid?
Bids
1
2 second fave
3
4 so far my fave
5
6 not big fan of the doubles
7

their all over bid the dog is only worth at most a 2021 rare. most of these offers are just taking pets from nothing in return but a simple monthly. i would strongly suggest you dont accept any of these because their all extremely over.

[rhaenyra]

this? <3

[Metax]

Im unsure about this trade! I guess i will be taking demand into account for this
ghostpants

unfair to you. to my knowledge, malk foxes have pretty high demand. as such, it depends on how much you value warrior cats. i personally wouldn't overpay by two '10 rares for one.

this? <3

both store pets are worth a 09 rare each so it depends on how much you value a VR

[$wag23]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93714050&userid=837278&signature=fTXdAWQvcZOeUVGmp3OqCg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93714094&userid=837278&signature=xtQFAy25-EYIzV4nYO4AFg

I need opinions on these trades please thank you!

[darling feathers]

this feels unfair to me but i’d like to check here first
xxx
(the bunny is from 2010)feathers

[Metax]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93714050&userid=837278&signature=fTXdAWQvcZOeUVGmp3OqCg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93714094&userid=837278&signature=xtQFAy25-EYIzV4nYO4AFg

I need opinions on these trades please :) thank you!

first one - Cream Fluffy Store Dog (worth 4 to 5 09' Rares to 1 MA) + Blue Fairy Goat (worth 4 to 5 09' Rares to 1 MA) = Cheshire Cat (2 MA's). i'd say roughly fair, but i'd add another 09 rare or two on their side due to cheshire cat demand.

second one - a 2013 store pet is worth 2 09 rares and 1 10 rare. let's value 2021 stores at an early 2011 rare. 4 giraffes + one rat = 5 early 11 rares, which add up to a late 09 rare. then there's the 19 store cat which is a 10 rare, plus the hamster rare, that's another 09 rare. lets leave in the 11, 12, 13 rares to make up for a 10 rare. to conclude - imho, unfair to them by around 3 17 rares.

this feels unfair to me but i’d like to check here first
xxx
(the bunny is from 2010)feathers

yeah, that's unfair to you. even if those are older items (or store), their value would add up to maybe like a 11 rare, if that.