The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[cowboycorvid]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93593343&userid=579410&signature=WlH2J4Y4JnKBgnYcxM05qg

does this seem fair? i'm incredibly bad at pet values haha

[jay]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93590070&userid=1001960&signature=OeJD5wozUhr5vETjyqCX4A
is this fair?

[useless witch]

Thoughts?

according to this list the buns is something like 3ma's the most and their rat is 0.25 to 0.5 nons so if you want to accept a rat go for it. Keep in mind that rats are considered less demand than buns, usually.

[Cøpacetic]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93593250&userid=881527&signature=Zwlrs4DpkRzcEf2GF6hVyA
Thoughts? I always get offered overs for this baby and it just makes me more reluctant to trade him lol

[kiro,,]

I'm not sure about the worth of these items?

all the items are worth about an uncommon from the same year, except the lilacs which im pretty sure are just a '21 common each, so theyre overtrading ^^

[Blue_Aussie]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93592989&userid=768234&signature=6pni-5dVkxQ6V6Xit9VT2Q

And this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93593481&userid=768234&signature=9AE-E4fuPAZo55qAIoarVg

Thank you in advance!

[Dead or Alive]

I’m not very good with items so I’m not sure if this is fair loll, thanks so much for the help!💫

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93593361&userid=911581&signature=gYsHxHcYrx_YyGpC5xl07Q

[kiro,,]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93593250&userid=881527&signature=Zwlrs4DpkRzcEf2GF6hVyA
Thoughts? I always get offered overs for this baby and it just makes me more reluctant to trade him lol

the lion doesnt have any special demand, so they are overtrading quite a bit compared to its actual worth

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93590070&userid=1001960&signature=OeJD5wozUhr5vETjyqCX4A
is this fair?

if you go by the 2/1 method, your side is about 2.75 '19 commons while there side is 4 '19 commons so theyre over ^^

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93592989&userid=768234&signature=6pni-5dVkxQ6V6Xit9VT2Q

theyre side is under! the cake dog is 2-3 MA, or 14-24 '09 rares, while their side is at 8.5 with no special demand pets.

I’m not very good with items so I’m not sure if this is fair loll, thanks so much for the help!💫

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93593361&userid=911581&signature=gYsHxHcYrx_YyGpC5xl07Q

i would say theyre over. not sure if the tunic is worth an '11 rare or an '11 uc but either way '21 store pets can go for a late '10 rare and the other items dont add up enough to roll the worth over to '10

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93593343&userid=579410&signature=WlH2J4Y4JnKBgnYcxM05qg

does this seem fair? i'm incredibly bad at pet values haha

i would say your side is over. the dog is from 2010 halloween, same year as the cat, and though warrior cats can get overtrades, regular sitting cats like that one typically dont have that much demand.


i'm not great at wording things so feel free to ask for clarification on anything you dont understand!

[sapphirelion]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93593343&userid=579410&signature=WlH2J4Y4JnKBgnYcxM05qg

does this seem fair? i'm incredibly bad at pet values haha

I would say that this trade is very unfair to you. Your pet is originally from Halloween 2010 (it’s a rerelease) which would make it worth about 3-5 Rares from 2010, and they only have one on their side.

I would get a second opinion on this though from someone who knows warrior cats and demand as I do not know if this sitting cat is a warrior cat or not, but if it is, it may have higher demand and in that case it may be fair

[EditPink]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93590410&userid=902320&signature=Y-e-Ajwcas9QNpUZLeSUDQ