The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[it depends]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93435578&userid=623277&signature=sHWcRqxuj82Rl6cgX4YkGQ
Is this fair

two 2013 rares equal a 2012 rare, add that with the other 2012 rare
and it'll be worth a 2011 rare. it isn't fair, a 2020 store pet would value around
a mid 2010 rare if i'm not mistaken, that and demand when it comes to bunnies.

[Ruruskadoo]

Could I please get some help with item trades?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93400283&userid=119355&signature=PR83RoC-R23_QG5V5nqhrg

and
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93426432&userid=119355&signature=zc1T3y6wG22CTBNy1QOUDA

[Syn_cat]

hi! I happened to get a few items trades and would like to know if they seem fair?

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=93438607&userid=737315&signature=jXSFbvZObjE-bHtOFwFLew

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=93438886&userid=737315&signature=UqGvqZgXFqGkdiSCuyXBiQ

3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=93438778&userid=737315&signature=3RFwKhJiDSHG0okHhl199w

Thank you C:

[~lucid~]

I recently got this trade and I want an opinion on it. Thanks in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93439086&userid=1011365&signature=gA8YILElcJ8hlAFPZf6e6Q

Edit: I had accidently copied another trade I was looking at from this topic instead of my trade. Sorry!

[attjje]

hiya !!! any idea if this is fair or if both sides have similar demand? they've mentioned they're happy to overpay.
follow-up question - any idea if skeleton pps for rose pps would be a fair trade? i'm uhhh. very out-of-date on what pets are going for these days gjhkfdhg

tysm for any help !!

trade

any input is helpful !! :)

[QueenSiren]

I feel like its not but is this fair? Is the rat a list or something?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93247075&userid=897504&signature=P7d8yCvUqZPyuGPVYnKqfA

[kmaybell]

I feel like its not but is this fair? Is the rat a list or something?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93247075&userid=897504&signature=P7d8yCvUqZPyuGPVYnKqfA

Hi! That is not fair. The rat is rereleased from 2010, there are no list pets below a vr C: (rare pets such as the shima lt can get enough demand to be traded at the value of list pets but there are no rares on any lists) It is not fair because there is a 2010 rare (the 2019 rr) on your side which already makes your side 1 09 rare worth with add and their side doesn't cover that.

[it depends]

hiya !!! any idea if this is fair or if both sides have similar demand? they've mentioned they're happy to overpay.
follow-up question - any idea if skeleton pps for rose pps would be a fair trade? i'm uhhh. very out-of-date on what pets are going for these days gjhkfdhg

tysm for any help !!

trade

any input is helpful !! :)

i'd say that the red rose and skeleton pps would be a fair swap...
both go around for 0.25 nons (3-4 ma's). same goes for the rose pps.
do get a second opinion though, since i'm not sure about demand.

[rosemary♥]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93439389&userid=623277&signature=WAfMr55KRSTMo6pQ2qaxjg
What does everyone think of this?

[iHolli]

{I received this suggestion w a Pink Heart Advent on their side [which I removed since I don't rly want to trade for it haha]. I'm currently asking what they were looking to trade but I feel like I'm underpaying currently? Especially to the bun.}
trade ×
{I'm treating the unknowns as rares since they were token trades.}

.Holli.