The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[godly]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93430224&userid=673614&signature=t8NkbP8VvpkphXD6J6zWLA
is this fair? it's an item trade

[Axolotl']

How does this trade look?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93436195&userid=613649&signature=D0h1eZhCFrjGAKvp-1FlUg
I know the moon tree dog had a bit of demand at some point, but does it still go for a 2009 rare? And what would their side add up to?
Thank you!

[kiwifyee<3]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93432613&userid=859775&signature=vyyt-2crV_vzSXlsKBN8Xw
how's this bid for my nonjewel? I really like it but im not sure if it's fair or not

[aloe.]

Just wanting to check that this trade is fair to me and my trading partner! (I'm willing to overpay considerably for the Fae Mischief event pets, especially the winged malk foxes due to their demand, and just want to make sure I am actually overpaying)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93402071&userid=941763&signature=-1_NgM2H1R4rKEHg_92VxQ

Thanks <3

Hey! I've been asking for a couple days now, and would really appreciate any input at all. I don't want to keep my partner waiting too long and risk cancelling <3 ty !

[attjje]

hiya !!! any idea if this is fair or if both sides have similar demand? they've mentioned they're happy to overpay.
follow-up question - any idea if skeleton pps for rose pps would be a fair trade? i'm uhhh. very out-of-date on what pets are going for these days gjhkfdhg

tysm for any help !!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93433583&userid=690207&signature=4G5gg1AsdeG2_AaavuupiQ

[Xanpoon]

Hello! I have theses bids for a Blue Toxic are any of theses trades fair? Thank you
- # 1

- # 2

-# 3

-# 4

-# 5

-# 6

[YellowOrigami]

i dont know if this is the right place to ask, but what would 2 rare 2010 Nicks pets be worth?
And I know my question is kinda broad, but if dates and rarities mattered, what would be considered a fair trade for those two rares? (I'm trying to trade someone and don't wanna under trade or overtrade too much)

[Mewfles]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93430224&userid=673614&signature=t8NkbP8VvpkphXD6J6zWLA
is this fair? it's an item trade

They are underpaying! your item is from 2014 whilst theirs are all more recent years, typically you can value any item but eggs as a common from that year
the eggs are from 2021, they only add up to at most an uncommon from 2019 due to demand atm, which will soon die out (probably already has) meaning togteher they aren't worth more than an uncommon from 2020, or a common from 2019, overall they are underpaying, I wouldn't do it

[starrine]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93436234&userid=56647&signature=1svsf3gfgQ76Y3IzUo9Icw

a little help, anyone? :] is this fair?

[LoveIsLove]

Hello I made this trade a few years ago when I was pretty new and was told it was kinda unfair but I was wondering if now that the store pets have gained value and the values of other pets have changed if this would be fair now?

Heres the trade!

I just want to know for future reference. Thank you so much for any help!