The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[kmaybell]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92793790&userid=419538&signature=CL9ydOdnI6u9c4SPiOJlMw ??

Because all the pets you asked for were newer that was actually not fair to you by a good bit. I see they cancelled so maybe its just because they didn't want to trade bulk away?

[nicole]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92793206&userid=1000928&signature=V1RuX4hkMuypmLOnSuTzFA

They said that they'd give 80 c$ I believe, unless I'm stupid and didn't get the full meaning of what they said. So, is that fair? Thanks! <3

This is unfair to you as Zodiac dogs can get 2-3 09 rares, or 150c$ for one zodiac dog.

[Daisystar]

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=92790956

[strawberry_dolly]

hi! so me and my fellow trader are trying to balance things out... im offering double the quantity of pets that im getting...but i still think this might be unfair to them? coz there is a very rare in their side....
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92793586&userid=1009721&signature=ld60IIuk-MMOlBE34kp2Wg
so how do i make this fair...after removing the very rare i think it might be overpay on my side...but im not really very sure...or should we just keep the vr and i still give those 24 pets for it? (i like the vr im willing to do that but i still dont know if that would be unfair to them) or remove the vr and i reduce the pets from my side somehow?
Yeah so im confused lol, any tips would be welcome

Their side with the very rare included is an overpay, but without the vary rare on their side your side is a tiny bit overpay because of the owl. Without the very rare they would need to add a tiny bit more! Hopefully that makes sense lol

-- just to add to this, since the very rare on their side is a 2018 store pet, it's worth about a late '09 rare making it massively overpay on their side! if you take out the very rare, you are indeed overpaying because of the 2012 UC
-- my maths is a little messy on this, but essentially without the owl, if you added 1 2018 VC I think it would be fair?
-- with regards to the very rare, your side (my maths might be a little off here), but in the simplest terms it comes to about 1 2012 UC, 1 2015 UC, 1 2016 UC and a 2019 VC, which wouldn't be equal to an '09 rare (I hope this makes sense!)

[little sunshine]

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=92790956

wrong link
please make sure to use the one provided at the bottom of the trade

[symphonycraze]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92787756&userid=990393&signature=JlN54HvL48H6zBGljU3zbA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92784585&userid=990393&signature=-_pK-t8W8hcV4EXpb_hpNQ

Help plzz:/

[lotusmoon9]

Thank you so much strawberry jam and swag
I removed the VR from their side and the owl from my side so that they can edit and choose what they think next

hi! so me and my fellow trader are trying to balance things out... im offering double the quantity of pets that im getting...but i still think this might be unfair to them? coz there is a very rare in their side....
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92793586&userid=1009721&signature=ld60IIuk-MMOlBE34kp2Wg
so how do i make this fair...after removing the very rare i think it might be overpay on my side...but im not really very sure...or should we just keep the vr and i still give those 24 pets for it? (i like the vr im willing to do that but i still dont know if that would be unfair to them) or remove the vr and i reduce the pets from my side somehow?
Yeah so im confused lol, any tips would be welcome

Their side with the very rare included is an overpay, but without the vary rare on their side your side is a tiny bit overpay because of the owl. Without the very rare they would need to add a tiny bit more! Hopefully that makes sense lol

-- just to add to this, since the very rare on their side is a 2018 store pet, it's worth about a late '09 rare making it massively overpay on their side! if you take out the very rare, you are indeed overpaying because of the 2012 UC
-- my maths is a little messy on this, but essentially without the owl, if you added 1 2018 VC I think it would be fair?
-- with regards to the very rare, your side (my maths might be a little off here), but in the simplest terms it comes to about 1 2012 UC, 1 2015 UC, 1 2016 UC and a 2019 VC, which wouldn't be equal to an '09 rare (I hope this makes sense!)

[Daisystar]

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=92790956

wrong link
please make sure to use the one provided at the bottom of the trade

Oh, whoops. This should be the link lol: trades/viewtrade.php?id=92790956&userid=945708&signature=CPRzmK43o1kcAvz8Eh9eNw

[skunksmell]

Is malk elemental for 3 store pets fair? Taking demand into account, what are the malk elemental cats going for?

[Feralfish]

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=92790956

wrong link
please make sure to use the one provided at the bottom of the trade

Oh, whoops. This should be the link lol: trades/viewtrade.php?id=92790956&userid=945708&signature=CPRzmK43o1kcAvz8Eh9eNw

It'd be unfair to you ; because despite it being two uncommon 2021 it's only equal a rare 2021 while the 2018 uncommon is like two 2018 commons which date wise makes it unfair to you.