The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[skunksmell]

Is malk elemental for 3 store pets fair? Taking demand into account, what are the malk elemental cats going for?

[Fishkin]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92793461&userid=644246&signature=6fj3PYA9tXAX_GemPl4Pmg
is this trade fair? :00

[$wag23]

hi! so me and my fellow trader are trying to balance things out... im offering double the quantity of pets that im getting...but i still think this might be unfair to them? coz there is a very rare in their side....
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92793586&userid=1009721&signature=ld60IIuk-MMOlBE34kp2Wg
so how do i make this fair...after removing the very rare i think it might be overpay on my side...but im not really very sure...or should we just keep the vr and i still give those 24 pets for it? (i like the vr im willing to do that but i still dont know if that would be unfair to them) or remove the vr and i reduce the pets from my side somehow?
Yeah so im confused lol, any tips would be welcome

Their side with the very rare included is an overpay, but without the vary rare on their side your side is a tiny bit overpay because of the owl. Without the very rare they would need to add a tiny bit more! Hopefully that makes sense lol

[Keqing]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92793461&userid=644246&signature=6fj3PYA9tXAX_GemPl4Pmg
is this trade fair? :00

if you check here the zodiac dogs trade away for 125-150 C$! so their 130 C$ seems reasonable, if anything you could ask for a tad more but the trade seems good to me

[kmaybell]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92793461&userid=644246&signature=6fj3PYA9tXAX_GemPl4Pmg
is this trade fair? :00

kinda/almost, zodiacs very consistently sell at 150 c$ (especially true date ones) so its up to you whether you want the extra 20 c$ :)

[~~Leafdapple~~]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92793206&userid=1000928&signature=V1RuX4hkMuypmLOnSuTzFA

They said that they'd give 80 c$ I believe, unless I'm stupid and didn't get the full meaning of what they said. So, is that fair? Thanks! <3

[$wag23]

Hi, is this okay, or am I underpaying them? (Im giving the 1 2016 common in exchange for 3 pets)
Should I be adding some more pets to get those?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92793082&userid=1009721&signature=LAUf0AYG-LlAoX1PWPICgg

On your side you should add a 2019 common! That would make it fair

[$wag23]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92793206&userid=1000928&signature=V1RuX4hkMuypmLOnSuTzFA

They said that they'd give 80 c$ I believe, unless I'm stupid and didn't get the full meaning of what they said. So, is that fair? Thanks! <3

Zodiac dogs are worth around 130c$-150c$, and the malk fish i believe is around 50c$, i could be wrong but i know its definitely around there. It would make it $130. However i do think you could get a better offer!

[Shallan]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92793790&userid=419538&signature=CL9ydOdnI6u9c4SPiOJlMw
I felt I was way overpaying, but they cancelled and said its not fair on their side?

[skunksmell]

Is malk elemental for 3 store pets fair? Taking demand into account, what are the malk elemental cats going for?