The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Dang It Moon Moon!]

Would this be fair?

[shepherd's dog]

Would this be fair?

math-wise this is fair.
on their side:

- x1 2009 rare
- x2 2010 rare ( = 1 2009 rare )
- x1 2010 rare
- x2 2010 uc ( = 1 2010 rare )

these last two (x1 2010 r + x2 2010 uc) equals out to an extra 2009 rare; which may seem like overpay, but the warrior cats definitely have high demand and you should typically expect to overpay. pets on your side (malk) have higher demand as well since old malk tend to be sought after and are harder to come across.

if you are trying to trade-up/have been looking for this cat, do it. even if not, i have found they're much easier to trade off/have better demand than then the malk pets you have atm. (not that they have low demand... but people sell arms and legs for warrior cats)

Quick opinions please? I dunno what my bat is worth
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92641067&userid=881527&signature=tbHW_34w4RDeKIZC2Q-DvA

i would consider this overpay for them. bats have low demand, even as older pets. these store pets have much higher demand, and could easily net multiple 2010 vr in an auction or similar demand context.

[LoveIsLove]

Is this fair to me?

What about this trade?

Thanks ahead of time for any help!

[Thinking.Kiwi]

Hello, I've just received [THIS] trade, and I'm somewhat tempted to accept, but my main goal is to get a Joker at some point so.... Do you guys think i could possibly get a joker with that re-release they're offering? is this fair? i really don't know how the value works for non-original dates :')

[Olive;]

Link

After the rares list got dismantled I’ve been less involved in the website and also now things don’t have "set" meaning anymore (not that the rares list was ever official). Could someone please help me determine the fairness of this?

[little sunshine]

Link

After the rares list got dismantled I’ve been less involved in the website and also now things don’t have "set" meaning anymore (not that the rares list was ever official). Could someone please help me determine the fairness of this?

very unfair to you
although the zebra has bad demand, the grapes are even worse
the zebra is valued around 1 non, whereas the grapes are barely 0.5

[DarkNights]

is this fair? i don't think I have the right idea of what this pets worth oops

or this one?

[beebun]

heya there! I was wondering about y’all’s opinion on this trade? thank you. <33

edit: aghhhhhh sorry changed the link

[little sunshine]

heya there! I was wondering about y’all’s opinion on this trade? thank you. <33

wrong link
make sure to use the one provided at the bottom on the trade

[kmaybell]

is this fair? i don't think I have the right idea of what this pets worth oops

or this one?

(to clarify this applies to rare warriors, not the very rare ones bc those are worth even more)
warriors go for 2-3 09 rares and can be sold for 100-150 c$!

with this in mind:
trade one- technically fair (if not slightly overpay on their side) but horses and rats do not have good demand so I would wait for a different species with better demand c:
trade two- very unfair to the warrior and their side isn't even worth a normal 09 rare

hope this helps!